CORE SECTION 1035 RULES AND PROCESS

1035 Exchange Mistakes That Can Make an Exchange Taxable

IMMEDIATE ANSWER

How a 1035 exchange can become taxable: wrong exchange direction, a check to the owner, money received, a different insured, and the federal rules behind each.

WHAT TO REVIEW

Facts like these can change how an exchange is treated. Review the whole transaction, and use the 1035 Exchange Assessment Calculator to list the issues to investigate.

What Makes a 1035 Exchange Fail: The Short Answer

A 1035 exchange can become taxable when it falls outside the exchange directions section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code lists, when the owner receives money or other property along with the new contract, when the contracts do not relate to the same insured, or when the owner takes a check instead of a direct exchange or assignment. Any of these can cause gain to be recognized.

This question usually comes from a policyowner or annuity owner who has started an exchange, or is about to, and wants to know which 1035 exchange pitfalls turn a planned exchange into a taxable event. 1035 Exchange maps the common 1035 exchange mistakes here, along with what the statute, the Treasury regulation and IRS guidance say about each, and the contract facts that decide how each one applies.

Why Getting the Structure Right Matters

Non-recognition is the whole benefit at stake. Section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the contracts it lists. Gain that has built up inside the original contract is not taxed at the exchange, which is the tax deferral the provision allows. The general framework, including the four permitted directions, appears in the site's explainer on section 1035 exchange rules. This page concerns what can go wrong.

When a transaction does not come within section 1035, the Code treats it like any other amount received under the contract. In Rev. Rul. 2007-24, the IRS addressed an owner who received a check under a non-qualified annuity contract and endorsed it to a second company to buy a new annuity. The ruling states that such a receipt "is treated as a taxable distribution, even if the check is endorsed to a second insurance company for the purchase of a second annuity." It concluded that the amount received was "taxable in 2007 to the extent set forth in § 72(e)," the year the owner received it.

Reporting reflects the difference. The IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 direct companies to "Use code 6 to indicate the tax-free exchange of life insurance, annuity, long-term care insurance, or endowment contracts under section 1035." The same instructions describe code 7 as the code used "to report a distribution from a life insurance, annuity, or endowment contract." A failed 1035 exchange is a distribution rather than an exchange, so it does not fit the code 6 description.

How Each Common Mistake Affects the Exchange

Seven 1035 exchange problems come up most often. Each has its own legal reason for taking the transaction outside section 1035.

Mistake 1: An exchange direction the statute does not list. Section 1035(a) lists four directions: "a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract"; "a contract of endowment insurance" for another endowment contract "which provides for regular payments beginning at a date not later than the date payments would have begun under the contract exchanged," or for an annuity contract, or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract; "an annuity contract for an annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract"; and "a qualified long-term care insurance contract for a qualified long-term care insurance contract." The list runs in one direction only. The Treasury regulation, 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1, states that section 1035 does "not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract. In the case of such exchanges, any gain or loss shall be recognized."

Mistake 2: Taking a check instead of a direct exchange or assignment. Rev. Rul. 2007-24 states: "The transaction is not characterized as a tax-free exchange under section 1035(a)(3) of the Code unless there is a direct exchange or assignment of the original contract." In the ruling's facts, the first company "disbursed a check" to the owner, who endorsed it to the second company. The ruling found that "Neither § 1035 nor the regulations make any special provision for the purchase of an annuity contract with amounts distributed to the policyholder under another contract."

Mistake 3: Receiving money or other property. "Boot" is the informal term for money or other property received along with the new contract. Under 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1, such an exchange "does not come within the provisions of section 1035," and the regulation points to section 1031(b) and (c). Section 1031(b) provides that the gain, if any, "shall be recognized, but in an amount not in excess of the sum of such money and the fair market value of such other property."

Mistake 4: A different insured or a different obligee. The regulation provides that section 1035 "does not apply to such exchanges if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured." For annuity-to-annuity exchanges it adds that non-recognition "is limited to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the contract received in exchange as under the original contract." An obligee is the person entitled to the contract's payments. Substituting a new insured, or a new obligee on an annuity, takes the exchange outside these rules.

Mistake 5: Changing the owner as part of the exchange. An ownership change made alongside an exchange can raise the obligee requirement above, as well as transfer-for-value and information-reporting questions. The IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 note that, under Treasury regulations, a section 1035 exchange can constitute a reportable policy sale in limited circumstances. The consequences depend on the facts of both contracts and of the parties involved.

Mistake 6: A policy loan outstanding at the exchange. A policy loan is an amount the insurer advances against the contract's value. The IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 state that "the cancellation of a contract loan at the time of the exchange may be taxable and reportable on a separate Form 1099-R." The site covers this topic further in its page on a 1035 exchange with a policy loan.

Mistake 7: Sequencing around a partial exchange. A partial exchange moves only part of a contract's value. Withdrawals, surrenders or other transactions taken close in time to a partial exchange raise questions about how the combined steps are characterized. The answer turns on the order, the timing and the contracts involved.

The status of the new contract as a modified endowment contract is a related issue, addressed under tax consequences.

Potential Tax Consequences of a Failed Exchange

Section 72 of the Internal Revenue Code governs amounts received under annuity, endowment and life insurance contracts. When an exchange fails, the amount received is generally taxed under section 72(e). For amounts received on "complete surrender, redemption, or maturity," section 72(e)(5)(E) and (5)(A) provide that the amount is included in gross income "only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract." The "investment in the contract" is, under section 72(e)(6), "the aggregate amount of premiums or other consideration paid for the contract" minus amounts previously received that were excludable from gross income. That figure is often called basis.

For amounts received under an annuity contract before the annuity starting date, but not received as an annuity, section 72(e)(2)(B) includes the amount in gross income "to the extent allocable to income on the contract." Rev. Rul. 2007-24 describes this as taxation "on an income-first basis."

Additional taxes may also apply. Section 72(q) increases tax by "10 percent of the portion of such amount which is includible in gross income" for amounts received under an annuity contract, subject to exceptions. Section 72(v) imposes the same 10 percent additional tax on amounts received "under a modified endowment contract." It does not apply to distributions "made on or after the date on which the taxpayer attains age 59½," those "attributable to the taxpayer's becoming disabled," or those that are part of "a series of substantially equal periodic payments." Whether any exception applies depends on the taxpayer's own facts.

Money or other property. In an exchange that would otherwise qualify, section 1031(b) recognizes gain up to "the sum of such money and the fair market value of such other property." Section 1031(c) provides that "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized."

Losses. Section 1035(a) states that "No gain or loss shall be recognized" on a qualifying exchange, and section 1031(c) states that "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." The tax treatment of any particular loss depends on the facts of the contracts.

Modified endowment contract (MEC) status. Section 7702A(a) defines a modified endowment contract as any contract meeting the federal tax definition of a life insurance contract which "is entered into on or after June 21, 1988, and" which "fails to meet the 7-pay test of subsection (b)," or "which is received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1) or this paragraph." A life insurance contract received in exchange for a MEC is therefore itself a MEC. An annuity contract received in exchange for one does not meet that life insurance definition and so is not a MEC under section 7702A. Section 7702A(c)(3) also treats a contract with a "material change" as "a new contract entered into on the day on which such material change takes effect" for the 7-pay test. For a MEC, section 72(e)(10) applies the income-first rule of paragraph (2)(B) and the loan rule of paragraph (4)(A), and section 72(v) can add the 10 percent tax.

Aggregation. Section 72(e)(12) provides that "all annuity contracts issued by the same company to the same policyholder during any calendar year shall be treated as 1 annuity contract," and applies the same rule to modified endowment contracts, for determining the amount includible in gross income.

Have Questions About Your Policy?

Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!

Structuring Problems That Create 1035 Exchange Pitfalls

The method of transfer is the most frequent structural failure. Rev. Rul. 2007-24 requires "a direct exchange or assignment of the original contract." It describes two qualifying patterns: an owner who "assigned the contract" to a second company in exchange for a new contract, and a "direct transfer" of the old contract's cash value from one company to the other in exchange for the new contract. Rev. Rul. 2007-24 also notes that Rev. Rul. 2002-75 concluded that an individual's assignment of an annuity contract to a second company, which then deposits the assigned contract's cash surrender value into a pre-existing annuity contract owned by the same taxpayer, qualifies as an exchange under § 1035. By contrast, Rev. Rul. 2007-24 holds that a check received by the owner and endorsed to a second company does not qualify, and that amount is taxable to the extent set forth in § 72(e).

An exchange may also be made within the same company. The IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 say that reporting is not required if "the exchange occurs within the same company," the exchange "is solely a contract for contract exchange" that "does not result in a designated distribution," and "the company maintains adequate records of the policyholder's basis in the contracts." The requirement of an exchange or assignment, rather than a payout to the owner, applies there as well.

Partial exchanges and the consolidation of several contracts carry their own structuring questions, including how basis is allocated and how nearby withdrawals are treated. The guidance on those questions is detailed, and its application depends on the contracts and the sequence of steps.

Exchange paperwork, form numbers and processing steps vary by carrier and are confirmed with both carriers. State replacement and suitability rules also vary by state, and the carriers handle the replacement paperwork.

Hypothetical Example: How a Structuring Mistake Triggers Tax

This example is hypothetical. It uses round figures, represents no reader's result, and ignores surrender charges, additional taxes and every other fact not stated.

Assumptions:

  • One owner holds a non-qualified annuity contract, with no loans and no prior withdrawals.
  • The investment in the contract (basis) is $80,000.
  • The accumulated value is $120,000.
  • The owner wants a new annuity contract with the same owner and obligee.

Version A: the owner takes a check. The first company surrenders the contract and issues a $120,000 check to the owner, who endorses it to a second company.

  1. Amount received: $120,000.
  2. Less investment in the contract: $80,000.
  3. Amount over the investment: $120,000 − $80,000 = $40,000.

Under Rev. Rul. 2007-24, this is a taxable distribution. The $40,000 is included in gross income in the year received, under section 72(e).

Version B: a direct exchange or assignment. The owner assigns the contract, and its $120,000 value goes directly to the new annuity contract with no money paid to the owner.

  1. Gain inside the contract: $40,000.
  2. Gain recognized under section 1035(a): none, because the statute provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized" on a qualifying annuity-for-annuity exchange.
  3. Basis of the new contract under section 1031(d): "the same as that of the property exchanged," here $80,000, with no money received and no gain recognized to adjust it.

The $40,000 gain is not eliminated in Version B. It remains in the new contract, with the $80,000 basis carried over. Actual consequences depend on the facts of the contracts involved.

Questions to Ask Before Completing an Exchange

These questions help show whether any common 1035 exchange mistake is present. The answer to each turns on the facts of the contracts.

  • Is the direction one that section 1035(a) lists: life insurance to life insurance, endowment, annuity or qualified long-term care; endowment to a qualifying endowment, annuity or qualified long-term care; annuity to annuity or qualified long-term care; or qualified long-term care to qualified long-term care?
  • Will the transaction be a direct exchange or assignment, with no check issued to the owner?
  • Will any money or other property be received alongside the new contract?
  • Do both contracts relate to the same insured, and, for annuities, the same obligee or obligees?
  • Is a policy loan outstanding on the original contract?
  • Will the owner change as part of the transaction?
  • Is the original contract a modified endowment contract, or could the new contract become one, or undergo a material change?
  • For a partial exchange, what other withdrawals or transactions are planned before or after it, and when?

Potential Alternatives When an Exchange May Not Qualify

Some situations leave no section 1035 path. Where the desired direction is not listed, such as an annuity contract for a life insurance contract, 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that "any gain or loss shall be recognized." The transaction is then a surrender and a separate purchase.

A surrender followed by a new purchase remains possible in any case. On a complete surrender, section 72(e)(5)(A) and (5)(E) provide that the amount received is included in gross income only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract. The site compares the two paths in its page on 1035 exchange vs surrender, and it compares an exchange with a policy loan on another page.

Money or other property received as part of the transaction has its own tax effect under section 1031(b) and (c). A loan cancelled at the exchange is a separate matter: whether and how it is taxed needs individual review. Keeping the original contract and making no exchange avoids the transaction altogether. This page does not evaluate whether that suits any owner. Which alternatives exist depends on both contracts and is confirmed with both carriers and a qualified tax professional.

What to Check

The contract facts come first. These include the investment in the contract, the accumulated value, any outstanding loan balance, the insured and the owner on both contracts, and the contract type of the original and the new contract.

Both carriers can confirm whether the transaction will be processed as a direct exchange or assignment rather than as a distribution and new purchase. They can also confirm the exchange paperwork, procedures and timing, which vary by carrier and contract.

Policy loans, ownership or insured changes, partial exchange structuring, MEC status and transaction sequencing each need individual review of the contracts involved, by the insurers and a qualified tax professional.

Have Questions About Your Policy?

Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!

FREQUENT QUESTIONS

Questions & answers

What happens if a 1035 exchange fails?

A failed 1035 exchange is generally treated as a taxable distribution from the original contract. The amount received is taxed under section 72(e) in the year it is received, and section 72(q) or 72(v) may add a 10 percent tax unless an exception applies. Rev. Rul. 2007-24 is the IRS ruling that addresses this outcome for a check endorsed to a second company.

Why does taking a check make a 1035 exchange taxable?

Rev. Rul. 2007-24 holds that an owner's receipt of a check under a non-qualified annuity contract "is treated as a taxable distribution, even if the check is endorsed to a second insurance company." The ruling requires "a direct exchange or assignment of the original contract." It notes that neither section 1035 nor the regulations provide for buying a contract with amounts already distributed to the owner.

Does a 1035 exchange need to involve the same insured?

Yes. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that section 1035 does not apply "if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured." For annuity exchanges, it also requires the same obligee or obligees under both contracts.

Can a 1035 exchange happen within the same insurance company?

Yes. The IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 describe an exchange that "occurs within the same company" and state the conditions under which it need not be reported on Form 1099-R. The transaction is still an exchange of contracts rather than a payout to the owner.

Is a failed 1035 exchange reported to the IRS differently?

Generally, yes. The IRS instructions reserve code 6 for "the tax-free exchange" of contracts under section 1035, and they describe code 7 for "a distribution from a life insurance, annuity, or endowment contract." The coding on any particular form is determined by the issuing company from the transaction's facts.

What are the most common 1035 exchange mistakes?

The common 1035 exchange mistakes include: - an exchange direction section 1035(a) does not list; - a check issued to the owner instead of a direct exchange or assignment; - money or other property received with the new contract; - a different insured or obligee; - an ownership change made as part of the exchange; - an outstanding policy loan; - withdrawals sequenced close to a partial exchange.

Can a failed exchange be fixed by buying a new contract with the proceeds?

Rev. Rul. 2007-24 indicates that it cannot. The ruling treats a check endorsed to a second company for a new annuity as a taxable distribution, because there was no direct exchange or assignment of the original contract.

This content is general educational information, not individualized tax, legal, insurance or financial advice. Contract terms and transaction facts require independent review.
PRIMARY / AUTHORITATIVE SOURCES

Remain Life Insurance Services, LLC