1035 Exchange vs Surrender: Exchanging a Contract or Cashing It Out
A 1035 exchange vs surrender compared under federal law: when gain is recognized, how basis carries over or is recovered, and the contract facts that matter.
Published October 6, 2026 · Updated October 10, 2026
Short Answer: The Core Difference Between an Exchange and a Surrender
A section 1035 exchange moves the value of a life insurance or annuity contract into another permitted contract, and section 1035 provides that no gain or loss shall be recognized on a qualifying exchange. A surrender ends the contract for its cash value, and any amount above the owner's investment in the contract is generally included in income that year.
Owners who weigh a surrender vs 1035 exchange usually hold a contract they no longer want in its current form and are deciding whether to cash it out or carry its value forward. 1035 Exchange compares the two paths on tax timing, cost basis, existing guarantees, surrender charges, a new surrender period, the death benefit, contract features, liquidity, policy loans and long-term economics.
At-a-Glance Comparison Table
| Criterion | Section 1035 Exchange | Surrender |
|---|---|---|
| Federal income tax on gain at the time of the transaction | Under 26 U.S.C. § 1035(a), "no gain or loss shall be recognized" on a qualifying exchange; gain is deferred, not erased | Amount received above the investment in the contract is included in gross income (26 U.S.C. § 72(e)(5)(E); § 61(a)(9)) |
| Treatment of cost basis in the new or successor contract | Basis "shall be the same as that of the property exchanged," with the adjustments in 26 U.S.C. § 1031(d) | No successor contract; the investment in the contract is recovered against the amount received |
| Effect on existing contract guarantees and riders | Old contract ends; its guarantees and riders do not carry over | Old contract ends; its guarantees and riders end |
| Surrender charges imposed by the existing contract | Set by the contract's terms; confirm with the insurers involved | Set by the contract's terms; confirm with the insurers involved |
| New surrender period on a replacement or new contract | New contract may carry its own schedule; varies by contract | None unless a new contract is bought; varies by contract |
| Death benefit continuity | Depends on the new contract's terms and underwriting | Death benefit ends |
| Access to cash and liquidity after the transaction | No cash to the owner at exchange; later access depends on the new contract | Net cash surrender value paid to the owner |
| Policy loan treatment | Turns on the specific loan and contract | Loan reduces net proceeds; turns on the specific loan and contract |
| Long-term economic trajectory | Deferred gain stays embedded in the new contract; varies by contract | Tax recognized now; reinvestment starts from after-tax amount; varies by contract |
This table is a general summary. Individual contracts differ, and each row depends on the facts of the contracts involved, which are confirmed with the insurers and a qualified tax professional.
Tax Timing: When Gain Is Recognized
The moment of recognition is where the two paths divide most sharply. Section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code provides that "no gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the contracts it lists: "a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract"; a contract of endowment insurance for another endowment contract "which provides for regular payments beginning at a date not later than the date payments would have begun under the contract exchanged," or for an annuity contract, or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract; "an annuity contract for an annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract"; and a qualified long-term care insurance contract for another one.
The Treasury regulation adds limits. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that "section 1035 does not apply to such exchanges if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured," and that an annuity-for-annuity exchange "is limited to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the contract received in exchange as under the original contract." It also states that "This section and section 1035 do not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract. In the case of such exchanges, any gain or loss shall be recognized." Exchanges are generally carried out as direct transfers between the insurers; an owner who takes the cash personally has, in substance, surrendered, and whether a given transaction was carried out that way turns on its specific facts.
A surrender follows a different rule. Section 61(a)(9) lists "Income from life insurance and endowment contracts" among items of gross income, and section 72(e)(5)(E) reaches "any amount received under a contract on its complete surrender, redemption, or maturity," which is included in gross income "only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract." For annuity contracts, section 72(q) adds a 10 percent additional tax on the includible portion of certain amounts received, subject to exceptions in that subsection; whether it applies depends on the facts of the contract.
The exchange's non-recognition is a deferral. The gain built into the old contract travels with the new one through the basis rules.
Cost Basis: Carried Over in an Exchange, Recovered in a Surrender
Basis, called the "investment in the contract" in section 72(e)(6), is generally "the aggregate amount of premiums or other consideration paid for the contract," minus amounts received earlier that were excludable from gross income.
In an exchange, 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that basis "shall be governed by section 1031(d)." Section 1031(d), whose text names section 1035(a), provides that "the basis shall be the same as that of the property exchanged, decreased in the amount of any money received by the taxpayer and increased in the amount of gain or decreased in the amount of loss to the taxpayer that was recognized on such exchange." The old basis carries over; it does not reset to the new contract's value. Where money or other property is also received, section 1031(b) recognizes gain "in an amount not in excess of the sum of such money and the fair market value of such other property," section 1031(c) recognizes no loss, and the regulation says such an exchange "does not come within the provisions of section 1035." That additional money or property is often called boot.
In a surrender, there is no successor contract. The investment in the contract is recovered against the amount received, and only the excess is included in gross income under section 72(e)(5)(E).
Combining an annuity into an existing contract, or exchanging only part of a contract, raises separate basis-allocation questions that IRS rulings address. How a partial exchange is treated depends on the facts of the contracts involved and is confirmed with the insurers and a qualified tax professional.
Hypothetical example. Assume a contract with a $60,000 investment in the contract, a $100,000 cash value, no loan, no surrender charge, and a full exchange with owner and insured unchanged.
- Built-in gain: $100,000 − $60,000 = $40,000.
- Exchange: no gain recognized; basis in the new contract stays $60,000; the $40,000 remains embedded.
- Surrender: $100,000 received − $60,000 investment = $40,000 included in gross income.
Existing Guarantees: What Stays and What May Not
Applied to the whole contract, neither path preserves the old contract. A surrender terminates the existing contract permanently, along with its guarantees, riders and benefits, such as a guaranteed minimum interest rate described in the contract. An exchange also terminates the existing contract; its guarantees do not transfer to the new one.
Whether a new contract offers comparable features depends entirely on that contract's terms. Carrier forms, procedures and product availability vary by carrier and are confirmed with both carriers. 1035 Exchange names no insurer, carrier or product. Any change of owner or insured in connection with an exchange is weighed against the regulation's same-insured requirement, and for annuities its same-obligee requirement.
Surrender Charges: The Cost of Leaving the Existing Contract
Surrender charges, the fees some contracts impose when value is withdrawn during a set period, come from the contract, not from federal tax law. Their amount, schedule, any waiver and any free-withdrawal amount vary by contract and carrier.
Section 1035 says nothing about them. The existing contract's terms decide whether a charge applies when its value leaves by exchange, just as they decide what applies on surrender. These details are confirmed with the existing carrier; another page on 1035 Exchange looks at surrender charges in exchanges more closely.
New Surrender Period: Starting the Clock Again
A different question arises on the receiving side. A new contract issued in an exchange may carry its own surrender charge schedule measured from its issue date, a contractual matter rather than a federal tax rule. An owner who surrenders and then buys a new contract with the proceeds generally faces the same feature on the new contract.
The length and structure of any new surrender period vary by contract and carrier and are confirmed with the new carrier. The time a carrier-to-carrier transfer takes also varies by carrier and contract and is confirmed with both carriers.
Death Benefit: Continuity and Gaps
For life insurance, a surrender ends the death benefit; nothing remains in force afterward. An exchange substitutes a new contract, whose death benefit depends on its own terms and any underwriting, meaning the insurer's evaluation of the insured.
There may be a period between the end of the old contract and the issue of the new one during which no death benefit is in force; how the insurers handle that timing varies by carrier and contract, as does the order of steps.
Tax status can follow the exchange. A modified endowment contract (MEC) is a life insurance contract entered into on or after June 21, 1988, that fails the 7-pay funding test in section 7702A. Under 26 U.S.C. § 7702A(a)(2), a MEC includes any contract "received in exchange for" a MEC. For MECs, section 72(e)(10) applies the income-first allocation and treats loans as distributions, and section 72(v) adds a 10 percent additional tax on the includible portion of amounts received, subject to its exceptions. Whether a particular contract is a MEC depends on its funding history and the date it was entered into.
Have Questions About Your Policy?
Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!
Contract Features: Riders, Options and Benefits
Riders, living benefits, credited rates and similar terms belong to the contract that contains them. A surrender ends them all. An exchange moves value, not features: the new contract's own terms decide what it offers, and whether those terms are comparable is a contractual question that varies by carrier and product.
Changes can also affect MEC testing. Section 7702A(c)(3) provides that after a "material change in the benefits under (or in other terms of) the contract," the contract "shall be treated as a new contract entered into on the day on which such material change takes effect," for the 7-pay test. Whether an exchange or a change in benefits triggers this turns on the specific contract and is confirmed with a qualified tax professional.
Liquidity: Access to Cash After the Transaction
Cash in hand is the clearest practical contrast. A surrender pays the owner the net cash surrender value, after any surrender charges and any loan balance, and the includible gain is reported for that tax year under sections 61(a)(9) and 72(e).
An exchange, carried out as a transfer between insurers, generally puts no cash in the owner's hands. Later access depends on the new contract's terms, including any new surrender period. An owner who needs cash now is in a different position from one who does not, and how that need weighs against the other factors is a fact-specific matter.
Policy Loans: An Enhanced-Review Topic
Policy loans need individual review of the contracts involved and a qualified tax professional. A policy loan is money the insurer advances against the contract's value.
On a surrender, an outstanding loan generally reduces the net cash the owner receives; how the loan balance enters the tax computation depends on the contract and the applicable Code provisions. In an exchange, a loan cancelled when the old contract ends may be taxable, and how a loan is handled varies by carrier. Section 72(e)(4)(A), which treats loans as distributions for MECs through section 72(e)(10), adds another layer. Another page on 1035 Exchange covers exchanges with loans in more detail.
Long-Term Economics: How Each Path Plays Out Over Time
Over time, the paths differ in when tax is paid and what continues to grow. Under an exchange, the deferred gain stays embedded through the carryover basis and is generally recognized when the new contract is later surrendered or distributed. A surrender recognizes the gain now, so the amount available to reinvest is the after-tax amount.
What the difference is worth depends on the size of the built-in gain, the owner's tax rate at the time of any future distribution, the new contract's features and costs, and how long it is held. Fees, credited rates, cost of insurance charges and other contract economics vary by contract and carrier and are confirmed with the carriers. 1035 Exchange computes no result and does not suggest that either path produces a better outcome.
When a Section 1035 Exchange May Fit
A policyowner who considers an exchange typically holds a contract with meaningful built-in gain and has no present need for cash. Another common situation is an owner who wants a different contract type within the directions section 1035(a) lists, such as life insurance to annuity, annuity to annuity, endowment to annuity, or into a qualified long-term care insurance contract. Some owners hold contracts whose features no longer match their circumstances and are comparing a new contract's terms as a factual matter.
Whether a particular exchange meets section 1035 depends on the facts of the contracts involved and is confirmed with both carriers and a qualified tax professional.
When a Surrender May Fit
Owners who weigh a surrender commonly need the cash value now. Others hold a contract with little built-in gain, or one whose cash value is below the investment in the contract; whether a loss on surrender has any tax effect depends on the facts of that contract.
A surrender also comes up when the desired move is outside section 1035, such as an annuity for life insurance, which 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 excludes. Some owners simply want no replacement contract. The tax consequences turn on the investment in the contract and the amount received.
Decision Framework: Questions to Consider
- How large is the built-in gain relative to the contract's cash value?
- Is immediate cash part of the purpose?
- Is the destination contract within the directions section 1035(a) lists?
- Does the existing contract have an outstanding loan?
- Is the existing contract a MEC?
- Would the owner or insured change?
- Do the existing contract's surrender charges make either path costly?
- How would a new surrender period on a replacement contract affect access to value?
An outstanding loan, MEC status, any change of owner or insured, and the tax effect of any loss on surrender need individual review; the rest depends on the facts of the owner's contracts and is confirmed with both carriers and a qualified tax professional.
Example Scenarios (Hypothetical)
Hypothetical Example 1: full exchange of an annuity. Assumptions: nonqualified annuity, $50,000 investment in the contract, $80,000 cash value, no loan, no surrender charge, no money or other property received, full exchange into another annuity with the same obligee.
- Built-in gain: $80,000 − $50,000 = $30,000.
- Gain recognized at exchange under section 1035(a): $0.
- Basis in the new annuity under section 1031(d): $50,000 (same as the old, with no money received and no gain recognized).
- Gain still embedded: $80,000 value − $50,000 basis = $30,000.
Hypothetical Example 2: surrender of the same annuity. Same assumptions, but the owner surrenders.
- Amount received: $80,000.
- Investment in the contract: $50,000.
- Amount included in gross income under section 72(e)(5)(E): $80,000 − $50,000 = $30,000.
These examples are not any reader's result; actual results depend on the facts of the reader's contracts, including charges and any additional tax.
Questions to Ask Before Choosing
For the existing carrier: What is the current cash surrender value? What is the investment in the contract? Are there outstanding loans? What surrender charges apply? Is the contract a MEC?
For the new carrier: What are the new contract's surrender charge schedule and free-withdrawal provisions? What features, riders and guarantees does it offer? Will it accept a section 1035 exchange?
For a qualified tax professional: What are the federal income tax consequences of each path on these contract facts? Does the proposed exchange meet section 1035 and 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1?
Carrier forms, procedures and timing vary by carrier and are confirmed with both carriers. State replacement and suitability rules vary by state, and the carriers handle the replacement paperwork.
Have Questions About Your Policy?
Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!
Questions & answers
Do I have to pay taxes on a surrendered life insurance policy?
A surrender generally produces taxable income to the extent the amount received exceeds the investment in the contract. Section 72(e)(5)(E) includes amounts received on complete surrender in gross income "only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract," and section 61(a)(9) lists income from life insurance contracts as gross income. Whether any amount is includible depends on the contract's facts.
Should I surrender my annuity or do a 1035 exchange?
That choice belongs to the owner, with the insurers and a qualified tax professional. The answer generally turns on the built-in gain, the need for cash, the destination contract, any surrender charges, any loan and the new contract's terms. Section 1035(a) addresses only the tax recognition of a qualifying exchange.
Is cashing out life insurance different from exchanging it for tax purposes?
Yes. Cashing out recognizes any gain above the investment in the contract under section 72(e), while section 1035(a) provides that no gain or loss shall be recognized on a qualifying exchange. The exchanged gain is carried into the new contract through section 1031(d) basis rules.
Can I exchange an annuity for a life insurance policy under section 1035?
No. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that section 1035 does not apply to "the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract," and that "any gain or loss shall be recognized" in such exchanges.
Is it better to surrender or sell a life insurance policy?
Neither is better in general; a sale to a third party is a separate transaction under different rules, covered elsewhere. 1035 Exchange compares surrender with exchange, a choice that turns on built-in gain, cash needs and permitted exchange directions.
How is cashing out an annuity taxed compared with a 1035 exchange?
On a complete surrender, section 72(e)(5) includes the amount received in gross income only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract. For annuity contracts, section 72(q) adds a 10 percent additional tax on the includible portion of certain amounts received, subject to exceptions in that subsection, and whether it applies turns on the specific contract. Section 1035(a) provides that no gain or loss shall be recognized on a qualifying exchange of an annuity contract for an annuity contract.
1035 Exchange vs Surrender-and-Replace
1035 Exchange vs Borrowing Against the Policy
Should You Do a 1035 Exchange? Questions to Answer First
When Not to Do a 1035 Exchange
1035 Exchange vs 1031 Exchange: Insurance Contracts, Not Real Estate
Exchanging an Underperforming Policy or Annuity Under Section 1035
