CORE SECTION 1035 RULES AND PROCESS

Surrender Charges and a 1035 Exchange: What the Tax Rules Do and Do Not Cover

SHORT ANSWER

Section 1035 governs whether gain or loss is recognized on an exchange. Surrender charges and any new surrender period come from contract terms set by the carriers.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATION

Taking possession of funds personally may create tax consequences and can jeopardize intended 1035 treatment.

Short Answer: What a 1035 Exchange Does and Does Not Do About Surrender Charges

No. A 1035 exchange does not remove surrender charges. Section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code decides only whether gain or loss is recognized for federal income tax purposes. A surrender charge, and any new surrender period on the replacement contract, comes from the contract terms each insurer sets. Both carriers are the source for those terms.

This question usually comes from an owner of a life insurance or annuity contract who is weighing an exchange. Two things worry that owner: a charge on the existing contract, and a fresh surrender period on the new one. 1035 Exchange explains the exchange rules of section 1035 for these contracts. This page covers what the statute provides, how surrender charges work as contract terms, and which contract facts decide the outcome.

Key Takeaways

  • Section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code provides that "no gain or loss shall be recognized" on the exchanges it lists among life insurance, endowment, annuity and qualified long-term care insurance contracts.
  • A surrender charge is a feature of an insurance or annuity contract, not of the tax code, and section 1035 does not waive it.
  • An exchange may bring a surrender charge on the existing contract if that contract is still within its surrender charge period, depending on the contract's terms.
  • A replacement contract may carry its own new surrender charge period, under terms the issuing carrier sets.
  • Whether a charge applies, how much it is, and how long a new surrender period lasts are confirmed with both carriers.
  • Surrender charges vary by carrier and contract, so this page states no charge figure or schedule.

What Section 1035 Is

Section 1035 is a federal income tax provision about exchanges of certain insurance contracts. Its general rule reads: "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the contracts it then lists. "Recognized" means counted for tax in the year of the transaction. The statute lists four directions:

  • "a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract";
  • "a contract of endowment insurance (A) for another contract of endowment insurance which provides for regular payments beginning at a date not later than the date payments would have begun under the contract exchanged, or (B) for an annuity contract, or (C) for a qualified long-term care insurance contract";
  • "an annuity contract for an annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract"; and
  • "a qualified long-term care insurance contract for a qualified long-term care insurance contract."

The Treasury regulation at 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 adds conditions. It states that "section 1035 does not apply to such exchanges if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured." That is the regulation's own wording. For annuity exchanges, it says the rule "is limited to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the contract received in exchange as under the original contract." An obligee is the person to whom the insurer owes the contract's obligations.

The regulation also sets an outer boundary. "This section and section 1035 do not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract. In the case of such exchanges, any gain or loss shall be recognized."

The statute says nothing about contract fees, surrender charges or the terms of a replacement contract. Those matters fall outside it. The site's overview of section 1035 exchange rules sets out the statute's scope in more detail.

How It Works

The method of the transaction matters as much as the contracts involved. A section 1035 exchange is generally carried out as a direct exchange or an assignment of the original contract, where the contract itself, not cash paid to the owner, is what moves. It can be made between two companies or within the same company. A surrender for cash followed by the purchase of a new contract is a different transaction. A complete surrender falls under the rules of section 72(e) for amounts received on a contract's "complete surrender, redemption, or maturity."

The paperwork, the forms each insurer uses and the timing of the transaction vary by carrier and by contract. Those details are confirmed with both carriers. The order of steps is one of the facts that decides how the transaction is treated.

Using the direct-exchange method does not, by itself, change the surrender charge. The existing carrier applies its contract terms to the transaction. Whether those terms treat an exchange as a surrender for charge purposes is a question for that carrier.

Eligible Contracts for a 1035 Exchange

Section 1035(a) names four kinds of contracts: life insurance, endowment, annuity and qualified long-term care insurance contracts. The destination allowed depends on the source contract:

  • a life insurance contract may go to another life insurance contract, or to an endowment, annuity or qualified long-term care insurance contract;
  • an endowment contract may go to another endowment contract with payments beginning no later, or to an annuity or qualified long-term care insurance contract;
  • an annuity contract may go to another annuity contract or to a qualified long-term care insurance contract; and
  • a qualified long-term care insurance contract may go to another qualified long-term care insurance contract.

The list runs in one direction only. Under 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1, the rule does not reach an endowment or annuity contract exchanged for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract exchanged for an endowment contract.

The statute also defines its terms. An annuity contract is one "which may be payable during the life of the annuitant only in installments." A life insurance contract is one "not ordinarily payable in full during the life of the insured."

Surrender charges appear on many kinds of contracts, including whole life, universal life, and fixed, indexed and variable annuities. These are product categories, not tax categories. Whether a particular contract has a surrender charge, and for how long, is a question for the carrier that issued it.

Have Questions About Your Policy?

Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!

Exchange Requirements and the Surrender-Charge Intersection

The tax requirements and the contract terms work on separate tracks, and they meet in only a few places.

The regulation's same-insured condition reads that section 1035 "does not apply to such exchanges if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured." Its same-obligee condition for annuity exchanges limits the rule "to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the contract received in exchange as under the original contract." A change of owner or insured as part of an exchange can therefore affect whether the rule applies.

When a transaction falls outside section 1035, its tax results are determined under the other rules of the Code, such as section 72(e) for an amount received on a complete surrender. Any surrender charge still applies as a contract matter, whatever the tax result.

A transaction that does meet section 1035 does not waive the existing contract's surrender charge either. The carrier applies its contract terms regardless of the tax treatment.

A related rule covers money or property received in the exchange. Section 1031(b), which by its text reaches exchanges under section 1035(a), applies where the owner receives "other property or money" along with the new contract. Gain is then "recognized, but in an amount not in excess of the sum of such money and the fair market value of such other property." That cash or other property is often called "boot." The regulation states that such an exchange "does not come within the provisions of section 1035." Whether a surrender charge has any bearing on these rules depends on the facts of both contracts.

Tax Treatment: What Section 1035 Defers and What It Does Not Touch

Deferral is the core of section 1035's effect, and its words are precise: "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the listed contracts. Gain that is not recognized at the exchange is not erased. It carries into the replacement contract through the basis rule, and it may be recognized on a later taxable distribution under the rules that then apply.

Basis is the tax measure of what the owner has in the contract. The regulation states that basis in a section 1035 exchange "shall be governed by section 1031(d)." Section 1031(d) provides that "the basis shall be the same as that of the property exchanged, decreased in the amount of any money received by the taxpayer and increased in the amount of gain or decreased in the amount of loss to the taxpayer that was recognized on such exchange." This page does not compute any owner's basis.

Losses have their own statutory language. Section 1031(c) provides, for exchanges that include other property or money, that "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." How any particular loss is treated depends on the facts of the contracts.

A surrender charge sits outside this deferral. Section 1035 does not reduce, waive or reimburse a charge. A charge lowers the value that moves into the replacement contract, which affects the economics of the exchange, but it is a contract term. Section 72(e)(3)(A) of the Code, which allocates certain amounts received between income and investment, measures a contract's cash value "determined without regard to any surrender charge." The Code chose its words on this point, and how they bear on a given contract depends on its facts.

Modified endowment contract status follows its own statute. Section 7702A(a) defines a modified endowment contract as a contract meeting the Code's requirements for a life insurance contract which "is entered into on or after June 21, 1988," and "fails to meet the 7-pay test of subsection (b)," or "which is received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1) or this paragraph." A contract received in exchange for a modified endowment contract is one itself only if it meets those life insurance contract requirements. For such contracts, section 72(e)(10) applies the income-first rules to distributions and loans, and section 72(v) imposes "an amount equal to 10 percent" on the includible portion of an amount received, with exceptions, including distributions made on or after age 59½.

Important Considerations: Surrender Charges on Both Sides of the Exchange

A policyowner looking at an exchange faces two separate surrender-charge questions, one for each contract.

The existing contract. If the contract is still within its surrender charge period when the exchange is made, the carrier may assess a charge on the value transferred. An annuity surrender charge in a 1035 exchange can arise because some annuity contracts carry multi-year surrender charge schedules, which vary by carrier and contract. The same question arises for life insurance contracts that have surrender charges. Some contracts include waiver provisions, and those vary as well.

The replacement contract. A new contract generally starts its own 1035 exchange surrender period, measured under that contract's terms. The new surrender period's length, its schedule and any free-withdrawal features are set by the issuing carrier.

Neither question has a federal tax answer. Charge amounts, schedules and waivers vary by carrier and contract, and they are confirmed with both carriers. State replacement and suitability rules, which govern disclosures in many replacements, vary by state, and the carriers handle the replacement paperwork.

When such a decision is evaluated, two economic factors are typically weighed. One is the cost of any charge on the existing contract. The other is the limit a new surrender period places on access to funds. This page describes those factors and does not weigh them for any reader.

An outstanding loan raises a further question. A loan at the time of exchange is a separate issue with its own tax treatment, covered on the page about a 1035 exchange with a policy loan. Several points need individual review of the contracts by the insurers involved and a qualified tax professional: policy loans, ownership or insured changes, partial exchanges, modified endowment contract status, and the sequencing of the transaction.

Common Mistakes When Surrender Charges Are Involved

Most errors in this area come from treating the tax rule and the contract terms as one thing. The following misunderstandings come up often:

  • Assuming section 1035 waives the charge. The statute addresses tax recognition, not contract fees.
  • Surrendering and repurchasing instead of exchanging. A surrender for cash is generally taxed under section 72(e) and can also bring any surrender charge. The comparison of a 1035 exchange vs surrender explains the difference.
  • Not asking the existing carrier first. Whether a charge applies to an exchange depends on that contract's terms.
  • Not asking the replacement carrier. The new contract's surrender period and schedule are terms of that contract.
  • Overlooking liquidity. A new surrender period may limit access to funds for the period its terms set.
  • Treating deferral as a gain. If a charge reduces the amount transferred, the deferred gain carries into a smaller contract value.
  • Overlooking partial transfers. A charge may apply to a portion of value moved in a partial exchange, and that depends on the contract's terms.

Example (Hypothetical)

This example is hypothetical. Its figures are round numbers chosen for illustration only.

Assumptions:

  • An existing non-qualified annuity contract has a cash value of $100,000.
  • Its investment in the contract, the premiums paid less amounts previously received that were excludable from gross income, as section 72(e)(6) provides, is $70,000.
  • The carrier's contract terms impose an assumed surrender charge of $5,000 on the exchange.
  • The exchange is assumed to be a direct exchange of one annuity contract for another, with the same obligee and no money or other property received.

Arithmetic:

  1. Untaxed growth in the contract before the charge: $100,000 − $70,000 = $30,000.
  2. Value transferred after the charge: $100,000 − $5,000 = $95,000.
  3. Under section 1035(a), on the stated assumptions, "no gain or loss shall be recognized" on the exchange.
  4. Under section 1031(d), the new contract's basis is "the same as that of the property exchanged," adjusted as that section provides. How the $5,000 charge bears on basis and future gain depends on the facts of the contracts.

The $5,000 is an economic cost set by the contract. It reduced the value on which future growth accrues. In this hypothetical it is not a tax event under section 1035. Actual charges, basis and tax results depend on the facts of the contracts involved.

Have Questions About Your Policy?

Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!

FREQUENT QUESTIONS

Questions & answers

Does a 1035 exchange eliminate surrender charges on the existing contract?

No. Section 1035 addresses whether gain or loss is recognized for federal income tax purposes, not a contract's surrender charge terms. Whether a charge applies to an exchange depends on the existing contract's terms, which the issuing carrier confirms.

Will a 1035 exchange start a new surrender period on the replacement contract?

Whether it does depends on the replacement contract's terms. The length and schedule of any new surrender period are set by the issuing carrier and confirmed with that carrier. The statute does not address them.

Do variable annuities have surrender charges?

Many variable annuity contracts include surrender charge schedules, but not every contract does. Whether a specific contract has one, and how much and how long it runs, are contract terms that vary by carrier. Both carriers are the source for those details.

Can a surrender charge on the existing contract create taxable income in a 1035 exchange?

The charge is a contract cost, not something section 1035 treats as a tax event. Section 1031(b) separately provides that gain is recognized, up to the money and the fair market value of other property received, when an otherwise qualifying exchange includes them. Whether a specific exchange produces a taxable amount depends on the facts of both contracts.

Does the amount of the surrender charge affect the cost basis in the replacement contract?

Basis in a section 1035 exchange is governed by section 1031(d), under which basis is "the same as that of the property exchanged," with the adjustments that section lists. How a charge that reduces the transferred value bears on basis depends on the facts of the exchange.

Which annuity contracts do not have surrender charges?

No federal rule sorts annuities by surrender charges. Some contracts are issued without them, and others carry schedules. The terms of a specific contract come from the carrier that issued it.

This content is general educational information, not individualized tax, legal, insurance or financial advice. Contract terms and transaction facts require independent review.
PRIMARY / AUTHORITATIVE SOURCES

Remain Life Insurance Services, LLC