POLICY AND CONTRACT TYPES

Variable Life Insurance in a 1035 Exchange

SHORT ANSWER

How section 1035 treats a variable life or VUL policy: the directions it permits, why annuity to life falls outside it, basis carryover and MEC status.

CONTRACT ANALYSIS

Variable life: what to review

  • Cash valueReview required
  • Cost basisReview required
  • Surrender chargesReview required
  • GuaranteesReview required
  • Policy loansReview required
  • RidersReview required

Short Answer: Can a Variable Life Policy Be Exchanged Under Section 1035?

Yes, a variable life or variable universal life policy can be the contract given up in a section 1035 exchange. Section 1035 treats it as a life insurance contract. The statute allows a life insurance contract to be exchanged for another life insurance contract, an endowment contract, an annuity contract or a qualified long-term care insurance contract without gain or loss being recognized.

Owners of these policies usually raise the question when they are weighing a move out of a policy whose cash value rides on investment subaccounts. The most common move is into an annuity. 1035 Exchange explains here how the federal exchange rules apply to that contract type. It covers the directions the statute permits, the one direction it excludes, and the contract facts that decide the outcome.

What Variable Life and Variable Universal Life Insurance Are

Variable life insurance is a form of permanent life insurance. Its cash value is allocated among subaccounts, which are investment options held in a separate account of the insurer. Because the cash value follows the performance of those subaccounts, it rises and falls. In some designs the death benefit rises and falls with it. Variable universal life (VUL) adds the flexible premiums and adjustable death benefit of universal life to that investment structure.

The federal tax label matters more than the marketing label. Section 1035(b)(3) defines a contract of life insurance as a contract with an insurance company that depends in part on the life expectancy of the insured but "is not ordinarily payable in full during the life of the insured." For the Code as a whole, 26 U.S.C. § 7702(a) provides that "the term 'life insurance contract' means any contract which is a life insurance contract under the applicable law." It adds the condition that the contract meet either the cash value accumulation test or the guideline premium requirements together with the cash value corridor. A variable policy that meets those requirements is a life insurance contract. That classification is what places a variable universal life 1035 exchange under section 1035(a)(1).

The subaccount menu, mortality and expense charges, administrative charges and transfer rules of a variable policy are contract terms. They vary by insurer and by contract and are confirmed with the insurer that issued the policy. The tax analysis of a VUL 1035 exchange does not change those terms. It addresses only whether gain or loss is recognized when the contract is exchanged.

How Section 1035 Treatment Applies to a Variable Life Contract

The core rule is short. Section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of—(1) a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract." "Recognized" means counted for tax in the year of the transaction. Nonrecognition is tax deferral. The gain built up inside the variable policy is not erased. It carries into the new contract through the basis rule of 26 U.S.C. § 1031(d), which 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 says governs "determination of the basis of property acquired in an exchange under section 1035(a)."

The Treasury regulation adds a condition about the person insured. After listing the permitted exchanges, 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that "section 1035 does not apply to such exchanges if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured." For exchanges of an annuity contract for another annuity contract, the same regulation limits nonrecognition "to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the contract received in exchange as under the original contract." An obligee is the person to whom the contract's obligations run.

The form of the transaction also matters. An exchange is generally carried out as a direct exchange or an assignment of the existing contract to the issuer of the new one. That can happen between two companies or within the same company. Surrendering the policy for a check and later buying a new contract is a different transaction from an exchange of contracts.

Section 1035 and section 1031 are separate provisions. Section 1031 governs like-kind exchanges of real property. Its subsections (b), (c) and (d) reach a section 1035 exchange only because their text expressly names "section 1035(a)." The identification and completion periods in section 1031(a)(3) apply to real property exchanges and play no part here.

Which Exchange Directions Are Permitted When the Existing Contract Is Variable Life

When the contract being given up is variable life or VUL, section 1035(a)(1) lists four destinations:

  • another contract of life insurance, including a new variable, universal, whole or indexed life policy;
  • an endowment contract;
  • an annuity contract;
  • a qualified long-term care insurance contract.

The direction readers ask about most is variable universal life to annuity. Section 1035(b)(2) defines an annuity contract as a contract with an insurance company depending in part on life expectancy "but which may be payable during the life of the annuitant only in installments." The statute does not distinguish variable, fixed or indexed annuities. A variable policy exchanged for any of the three falls within the life-to-annuity direction of section 1035(a)(1), provided the other conditions are met.

The directions run one way only. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that "This section and section 1035 do not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract. In the case of such exchanges, any gain or loss shall be recognized." An owner who moves a VUL policy into an annuity therefore cannot later move that annuity back into a life insurance policy under section 1035. Section 1035(a)(3) permits an annuity contract to be exchanged only for an annuity contract or a qualified long-term care insurance contract, so the permitted life-to-annuity direction does not imply the reverse. The site's page on exchanges section 1035 excludes sets out the full list. Other pages of 1035 Exchange treat the life-to-life and life-to-annuity directions more broadly.

Considerations Specific to the Existing Variable Life or VUL Contract

The facts about the existing policy usually decide how an exchange is analyzed. Several facts tend to matter.

Investment in the contract. This is the owner's basis, broadly the premiums paid less certain amounts already recovered. It is the figure that carries forward under section 1031(d). The insurer that issued the policy keeps the records from which it is figured.

Subaccount values on the exchange date. Because the subaccounts fluctuate, the value transferred is fixed only when the exchange is processed. How and when an insurer values the subaccounts for a transfer is a contract and administrative matter that varies by insurer.

Charges and riders. Mortality and expense charges, administrative charges and rider charges are set by the contract. They are confirmed with the insurer.

Policy loans, ownership and the insured. A loan outstanding when the policy is exchanged may have tax consequences. Same-insured and ownership conditions also apply. Five topics need individual review of the contracts involved by the insurers and a qualified tax professional: an outstanding loan, any change of owner or insured made in connection with the exchange, the modified endowment contract status of either contract, any exchange of less than the whole contract, and the order in which related transactions are carried out.

MEC status. If the existing variable policy is a modified endowment contract, that status already affects how amounts received from it are taxed before any exchange, and it can follow the policy into a new life insurance contract.

Considerations Specific to the Replacement Contract

What the owner receives determines which further rules apply. If the new contract is another variable life or VUL policy, it is a life insurance contract for tax purposes only if it meets 26 U.S.C. § 7702.

A new life insurance policy also raises modified endowment contract (MEC) questions. Under 26 U.S.C. § 7702A(a), a modified endowment contract is "any contract meeting the requirements of section 7702" which "(A) is entered into on or after June 21, 1988, and (B) fails to meet the 7-pay test of subsection (b), or (2) which is received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1) or this paragraph." In plain terms, a life insurance contract received in exchange for a MEC is itself a MEC. A contract can also become a MEC on its own terms if it is entered into on or after June 21, 1988 and fails the 7-pay test, a funding limit the statute sets.

Material changes reset the analysis. Section 7702A(c)(3)(A) provides that if there is a material change in the benefits or other terms of the contract, the contract "shall be treated as a new contract entered into on the day on which such material change takes effect," with adjustments for its cash surrender value. Section 7702A(c)(3)(B) includes any increase in the death benefit as a material change. It excludes certain increases attributable to premiums needed to fund the lowest level of benefits in the first seven contract years, or to interest or other earnings credited on those premiums. It also excludes, to the extent regulations provide, certain cost-of-living increases funded ratably.

If the new contract is an annuity, the MEC definition does not reach it. Section 7702A(a) applies only to a contract "meeting the requirements of section 7702," and an annuity contract is not a life insurance contract under that section. The annuity's own subaccounts, charges and features are set by its contract and vary by insurer.

State insurance replacement and suitability rules vary by state. The insurers handle the replacement paperwork those rules require.

Have Questions About Your Policy?

Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!

How Cost Basis Carries Over in a Variable Life Exchange

Basis is the measure of what the owner has already invested, and the statute tells how it moves. Section 1031(d) provides that if property was acquired on an exchange described in section 1035(a), "the basis shall be the same as that of the property exchanged, decreased in the amount of any money received by the taxpayer and increased in the amount of gain or decreased in the amount of loss to the taxpayer that was recognized on such exchange."

Hypothetical example. Assume a VUL policy has an investment in the contract of $40,000 and a cash value of $70,000. Assume also that it is exchanged by direct assignment for an annuity on the same insured and owner, and that no money or other property is received.

  1. Cash value transferred: $70,000.
  2. Basis in the old policy: $40,000.
  3. Built-in gain: $70,000 − $40,000 = $30,000.
  4. Money received: $0, so the basis is not decreased. Gain recognized: $0, so the basis is not increased.
  5. Starting basis in the annuity: $40,000 − $0 + $0 = $40,000.

The $30,000 is not recognized at the exchange. It remains inside the annuity. These figures are illustrative only and describe no reader's contract.

The result changes when something other than the new contract is received. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that where the property received includes "other property or money," the exchange "does not come within the provisions of section 1035" and refers to section 1031(b) and (c). Under section 1031(b), the gain "shall be recognized, but in an amount not in excess of the sum of such money and the fair market value of such other property." This cash or property is often called boot. Section 1031(c) provides that in such an exchange "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." How a particular loss is treated for tax depends on the facts of both contracts.

Surrender Charges and Variable Life Contracts

Many variable life and VUL contracts impose a surrender charge, a fee deducted when the contract is surrendered within a period the contract specifies. Whether and how that charge applies when the contract is exchanged is also a contract term. Schedules, amounts and periods differ by insurer and contract and are confirmed with the existing insurer. None is stated here.

Where a charge applies, it reduces the value that moves into the new contract. The replacement contract may carry its own surrender charge period, measured under its own terms. Section 1035 addresses the recognition of gain or loss. It does not address charges an insurer imposes. Whether a charge makes an exchange unattractive depends on the facts of both contracts. The site's page on surrender charges in exchanges covers the topic further.

Named Contract Features of Variable Life Contracts and What Happens to Them

Some variable policies carry contract features named by the insurer, such as features labeled as minimum benefits. Examples include a guaranteed minimum death benefit, a guaranteed minimum interest rate on a fixed-account option, or other riders. Each is a feature of that contract as the insurer wrote it.

An exchange replaces one contract with another. The features of the old contract end with it. The new contract has only the features its own terms provide. Whether a replacement contract offers similar, different or no comparable features is confirmed with the insurer that issues it. Section 1035 does not carry any contract feature across an exchange.

Policy Loans in a Variable Life Exchange

A policy loan is a loan from the insurer secured by the contract's cash value. A variable policy may have one outstanding on the date of an exchange. Whether an outstanding loan affects the exchange, and whether and how it is taxed, depends on the facts of both contracts and how the loan is handled at the exchange. The site's page on exchanges with policy loans describes the issue without resolving it for any contract.

A loan taken under a variable policy apart from any exchange is a separate matter. For a modified endowment contract, 26 U.S.C. § 72(v) provides that when a taxpayer "receives any amount under a modified endowment contract," the tax is increased by 10 percent of the portion includible in gross income. Exceptions apply for distributions made on or after age 59½, distributions attributable to disability, and certain series of substantially equal periodic payments.

How a Variable Life 1035 Exchange Is Carried Out

An exchange is a change of contracts, not a sale followed by a purchase. The existing variable policy is exchanged directly, or assigned, to the issuer of the new contract, either at another company or within the same company. The owner does not take the cash value in hand. A policyowner in this position typically completes the paperwork the receiving insurer uses. The insurers then handle the transfer of value and any replacement forms state law requires.

The forms, procedures, valuation dates and timing vary by insurer and contract and are confirmed with both insurers. No processing period is stated here. State replacement and suitability rules also vary by state. The general sequence is outlined on the site's page on the exchange process.

Potential Advantages of Exchanging a Variable Life Contract Under Section 1035

Deferral is the central feature. The comparison of exchange and surrender sets out that contrast. Basis also carries over under section 1031(d) rather than being used up.

A policyowner whose need for a death benefit has changed may consider whether an annuity fits the changed situation. An owner whose need continues may consider a different life insurance design. The answer turns on the facts of both contracts: surrender charges, the new contract's charges and features, MEC status and the owner's tax position.

Potential Tradeoffs of Exchanging a Variable Life Contract

Deferral is not elimination. The gain carried into the new contract remains subject to tax under the rules that govern that contract when amounts are later received. Other tradeoffs follow from the contract terms and the statutes:

  • A surrender charge on the old policy may reduce the value moved, and the new contract may start its own charge period.
  • A life insurance contract received for a MEC is itself a MEC under section 7702A(a).
  • Features of the old policy, such as a guaranteed minimum death benefit, end with that policy.
  • Subaccount choices and charges in the new contract may differ from those in the old one.
  • An annuity does not provide the life insurance death benefit treatment of 26 U.S.C. § 101(a), which excludes from gross income amounts received under a life insurance contract "if such amounts are paid by reason of the death of the insured." The return path to life insurance through section 1035 also closes.

Ownership or insured changes and the sequencing of related transactions add further facts that depend on both contracts.

Have Questions About Your Policy?

Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!

FREQUENT QUESTIONS

Questions & answers

Can a variable universal life policy be exchanged for an annuity under section 1035?

Yes, the direction is listed in the statute. Section 1035(a)(1) names an annuity contract as a permitted destination for a contract of life insurance, and a VUL policy that meets section 7702 is one. The regulation's same-insured condition and the direct form of the exchange also apply.

Can an annuity be exchanged for a variable life insurance policy?

No, not under section 1035. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that section 1035 does not apply to "the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract," and that in such exchanges "any gain or loss shall be recognized."

What happens to the MEC status of a variable life policy in an exchange?

It depends on the contract received. Under section 7702A(a), a contract meeting section 7702 that is received in exchange for a MEC is itself a MEC. An annuity is not a life insurance contract under section 7702, so the MEC definition does not reach it.

What happens to the subaccount investments when a variable policy is exchanged?

The value of the subaccounts at the time of the exchange is what moves to the new contract. The investment options of the old policy do not carry over. The new contract offers whatever subaccounts or crediting methods its own terms provide, confirmed with its insurer.

Can a variable life policy with a loan outstanding be exchanged?

A loan does not by itself appear in section 1035's list of conditions, but it can change the tax picture. Whether and how a loan outstanding at the exchange is taxed depends on the facts of both contracts and how the loan is handled, and it is not resolved here.

Does the death benefit survive a VUL exchange into an annuity?

No. The life insurance death benefit ends with the policy. Any death benefit under the annuity is a feature of the annuity contract. Section 101(a)'s exclusion applies to amounts paid under a life insurance contract by reason of the insured's death.

Can a variable life policy be exchanged for a new policy on a different insured?

Not under section 1035 as the regulation reads. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that section 1035 does not apply "if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured."

This content is general educational information, not individualized tax, legal, insurance or financial advice. Contract terms and transaction facts require independent review.
PRIMARY / AUTHORITATIVE SOURCES

Remain Life Insurance Services, LLC