Exchanging a Policy or Annuity Worth Less Than You Paid: 1035 Exchange Loss Rules
Section 1035(a) says no gain or loss is recognized on a listed exchange. See how that rule, section 1031(c) and the basis carryover apply to a contract with a loss.
Facts like these can change how an exchange is treated. Review the whole transaction, and use the 1035 Exchange Assessment Calculator to list the issues to investigate.
Published October 6, 2026 · Updated October 9, 2026
When a Contract Is Worth Less Than You Paid: The Short Answer
When a policy or annuity is worth less than the owner paid in, a qualifying section 1035 exchange does not let that loss be claimed at the exchange. The Internal Revenue Code provides that "no gain or loss shall be recognized" on a listed exchange, and the old contract's basis carries over to the new contract under section 1031(d).
This question usually comes from owners of variable annuities, variable life policies or other contracts whose value has fallen below their premiums, and who are weighing an exchange. The page covers federal rules only. State insurance rules on replacement, suitability and disclosure vary by state.
Why a Contract Can Show a Loss, and Why It Matters
Two numbers frame the issue. The first is the "investment in the contract," often called cost basis. Section 72(e)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code defines it as "the aggregate amount of premiums or other consideration paid for the contract before such date, minus" amounts received under the contract that were excludable from gross income. In plain terms, it is what the owner has paid in and not yet received back as amounts excluded from gross income.
The second number is the contract's value, usually its cash surrender value: the amount the insurer would pay if the owner cashed the contract in, after any surrender charge. A surrender charge is a fee some contracts impose for ending them early, and its amount varies by insurer and contract. For property in general, section 1001(a) describes a loss as "the excess of the adjusted basis ... over the amount realized." Applied loosely to a contract, an economic loss exists when the value is below the investment in the contract.
That gap can open in several ways. A variable annuity or variable life policy can fall with its investment accounts. Any contract can be reduced by charges, and a life insurance policy's cost of insurance is drawn from its value over time. A 1035 exchange annuity loss or a life insurance policy loss is therefore a common situation, not an unusual one.
Why it matters: an owner with a gain often looks at section 1035 because the gain is not recognized at the exchange. An owner with a loss faces the mirror image. The same statute that keeps a gain from being recognized also keeps the loss from being recognized. The exchange is not a way to realize the loss for federal tax purposes at the time of the exchange.
How the Loss Rule Operates in a Section 1035 Exchange
Section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" four kinds of contracts, listed in its own terms:
- "a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract";
- "a contract of endowment insurance (A) for another contract of endowment insurance which provides for regular payments beginning at a date not later than the date payments would have begun under the contract exchanged, or (B) for an annuity contract, or (C) for a qualified long-term care insurance contract";
- "an annuity contract for an annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract"; or
- "a qualified long-term care insurance contract for a qualified long-term care insurance contract."
The words "or loss" carry the weight on this page. Inside a qualifying exchange, the owner's economic loss is simply not recognized. The site's page on how a 1035 exchange is taxed covers the gain side of the same rule.
Section 1031(c) adds a related rule. It names section 1035(a) in its text and provides that where an exchange would fall within section 1035(a) except that the owner also receives "other property or money," then "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." Section 1031 itself deals mainly with like-kind exchanges of real property; its subsections (b) through (d) reach a section 1035 exchange only because their text names section 1035(a).
Basis is governed by section 1031(d), and the regulation at 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 confirms that "Determination of the basis of property acquired in an exchange under section 1035(a) shall be governed by section 1031(d) and the regulations thereunder." Section 1031(d) provides that "the basis shall be the same as that of the property exchanged, decreased in the amount of any money received by the taxpayer and increased in the amount of gain or decreased in the amount of loss to the taxpayer that was recognized on such exchange." The regulation at 26 C.F.R. § 1.1031(d)-1(a) states that where no part of the gain or loss was recognized, "the basis of the property acquired is the same as the basis of the property transferred by the taxpayer with proper adjustments to the date of the exchange." This is the sense in which a 1035 exchange can preserve basis: the old figure becomes the new contract's starting basis, under the statute's formula.
The loss rule applies only inside a qualifying exchange. The regulation at 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that section 1035 "does not apply to such exchanges if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured," and that an annuity-for-annuity exchange "is limited to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the contract received in exchange as under the original contract." An obligee is the person to whom the contract's obligations are owed.
Direction matters too. The same regulation states that "This section and section 1035 do not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract. In the case of such exchanges, any gain or loss shall be recognized." A permitted direction is never reversible by inference. The site's page on section 1035 rules sets out the qualifying directions in full.
Federal Tax Consequences When a Loss Sits Inside the Exchange
What the federal text settles is narrow. In a qualifying exchange, no loss is recognized at the exchange, and the new contract's basis is fixed by section 1031(d): the same as the old contract's basis, decreased by any money received, and adjusted for any gain or loss that was recognized. When no money is received and nothing is recognized, the regulation's words give the new contract the same basis as the old one, adjusted to the date of the exchange.
What the text does not settle is equally important. Neither section 1035, section 1031 nor their regulations states whether an economic loss that was not recognized at the exchange can later be deducted, recognized on a later surrender or lapse of the new contract, or used in any other way. That question turns on the facts of both contracts and on rules outside these provisions, and this page does not resolve it.
Section 72(e) does describe how amounts received under a contract are taxed. Before the annuity starting date, an amount not received as an annuity is generally included in gross income "to the extent allocable to income on the contract" and excluded "to the extent allocable to the investment in the contract." Section 72(e)(5)(E) applies a separate rule to amounts received "on its complete surrender, redemption, or maturity," which are included in gross income "only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract." Those provisions address income; they do not state how a shortfall below the investment in the contract is treated.
Contracts held inside qualified retirement plans and IRAs are a separate matter. Rollovers and transfers within those arrangements are governed by other Code sections, and their rules are not covered here.
Have Questions About Your Policy?
Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!
Structuring Issues That Can Complicate an Exchange Involving a Loss
Several features of a transaction can change the analysis.
Money or other property received. Section 1031(b) provides that where an otherwise qualifying exchange also delivers "other property or money," the gain "shall be recognized, but in an amount not in excess of the sum of such money and the fair market value of such other property." Such extra value is sometimes called boot. Section 1031(c) provides that even then "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." The asymmetry is the point for a contract with a loss: money received can bring gain into income, but it cannot make a loss recognizable. The regulation at 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 adds that such an exchange "does not come within the provisions of section 1035," with sections 1031(b) and (c) applying instead. Under 26 C.F.R. § 1.1031(d)-1(d), the basis of the property received in that case is the transferred basis "decreased by the amount of money received."
Policy loans. A policy loan is an amount the insurer advances against the contract's value. How an outstanding loan is treated when the contract is exchanged, whether it is carried into the new contract or cleared first, is a separate question that this page does not resolve. The site's page on exchanges with policy loans covers that topic.
Partial exchanges. Moving only part of a contract's value raises basis-allocation questions of its own, covered on a separate page of this site.
Modified endowment contract status. Section 7702A(a) defines a modified endowment contract, or MEC, as a contract meeting the Code's requirements for a life insurance contract which "is entered into on or after June 21, 1988, and" which "fails to meet the 7-pay test of subsection (b)," or "which is received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1) or this paragraph." A life insurance contract received in exchange for a MEC is therefore itself a MEC. An annuity contract received in exchange for one does not meet the Code's definition of a life insurance contract and is not a MEC under section 7702A. For a MEC, section 72(e)(10) applies the income-first rules of section 72(e)(2)(B), and treats loans as distributions under section 72(e)(4)(A); section 72(v) adds a 10 percent additional tax on the taxable portion of amounts received, subject to its exceptions, including distributions made on or after age 59½.
Ownership or insured changes. Because 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 turns on the same insured and, for annuities, the same obligee, a change of insured or owner made with the exchange can take the transaction outside section 1035.
How the value moves. A section 1035 exchange is generally structured as a direct exchange or an assignment of the old contract, made between two companies or within the same company, rather than as a payout of cash to the owner. The site's page on the direct transfer of value explains that distinction. The order in which steps happen, such as a loan payoff, an ownership change or a partial transfer before the main exchange, can also affect the result.
Policy loans, partial exchanges, MEC status, ownership or insured changes and transaction sequencing all need individual review of the contracts involved, by both insurers and a qualified tax professional.
Hypothetical: Basis Carryover When a Contract Has a Loss
This example is hypothetical. Its assumptions:
- An owner holds a nonqualified annuity with an investment in the contract of $80,000, and that figure is also the contract's basis.
- The cash surrender value on the exchange date is $60,000.
- The owner exchanges the whole contract for another annuity, with the same owner and the same annuitant, by direct exchange or assignment.
- No money or other property is received, and no loan exists.
Step 1, the economic loss. $80,000 investment minus $60,000 value = $20,000 below what was paid in.
Step 2, the exchange direction. An annuity for an annuity is a direction section 1035(a)(3) lists, and the stated assumptions meet the same-obligee condition of 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1.
Step 3, recognition. Under section 1035(a), "No gain or loss shall be recognized." The $20,000 shortfall is recognized at the exchange: $0.
Step 4, basis under section 1031(d). Start with the old basis of $80,000. Subtract money received: $80,000 − $0 = $80,000. Add gain recognized: $80,000 + $0 = $80,000. Subtract loss recognized: $80,000 − $0 = $80,000. On these assumptions, the new annuity's starting basis under the statute's formula is $80,000, while its value is $60,000.
What that $80,000 figure means for any later surrender, lapse or loss of the new contract is not stated by sections 1035 or 1031. Real basis figures depend on each contract's full history of premiums, withdrawals and charges, which this example does not reflect.
Questions to Ask Before Exchanging a Contract With a Loss
A policyowner in this position typically gathers answers to questions like these from both insurers and a qualified tax professional:
- What is the current investment in the contract, and how did the insurer calculate it?
- What is the current cash surrender value, and does it reflect any surrender charge?
- Is the exchange in a direction section 1035(a) and 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 recognize?
- Do both contracts relate to the same insured, and for annuities, the same obligee or obligees?
- Is there an outstanding policy loan, and what happens to it at the exchange?
- Will the new contract be a modified endowment contract under section 7702A?
- Will ownership or the insured change as part of the transaction?
- Will the value move by direct exchange or assignment, or would a check be issued to the owner?
- Will the owner receive any money or other property in the transaction?
- Which state replacement and suitability rules apply? These vary by state, and the insurers handle the replacement paperwork.
Alternatives When an Annuity or Policy Has a Loss
Several paths are generally compared, and none is described here as suited to any reader.
Surrendering the contract. A surrender ends the contract and pays out its cash surrender value. It is not an exchange, so section 1035 does not govern it. Section 72(e)(5)(E) addresses income on a complete surrender; how a shortfall on surrender is treated for tax is a separate question that the federal text supplied here does not answer. The site's page comparing a 1035 exchange vs surrender sets the two side by side.
Holding the contract. An owner may keep the contract in force. Whether its value changes, and how charges continue to apply, depends on the contract's terms.
Exchanging despite the loss. In a qualifying exchange, no loss is recognized and section 1031(d) carries the basis into the new contract. What the carried-over basis means later is the open question already described.
Surrender charges, product availability, procedures and timing vary by insurer and contract, and are confirmed with both insurers.
What to Check With an Exchange at a Loss
Documents and confirmations commonly gathered include:
- Current statements from the existing insurer showing the investment in the contract and the cash surrender value.
- The direction of the exchange, checked against section 1035(a); annuity or endowment to life insurance, and annuity to endowment, fall outside section 1035 under 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1.
- Confirmation from both insurers that the value will move by direct exchange or assignment rather than a cash payment to the owner.
- The treatment of any outstanding loan at the exchange, confirmed with both insurers.
- The expected MEC status of the new contract, confirmed with the receiving insurer.
- Whether any money or other property will be paid to the owner.
- State replacement and suitability requirements, which vary by state, confirmed with both insurers.
- A conversation with a qualified tax professional about the basis carryover, the unrecognized loss and any later surrender of the new contract.
Whether a particular exchange meets section 1035 is confirmed with both insurers and a qualified tax professional.
Have Questions About Your Policy?
Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!
Questions & answers
What happens to a loss when a life insurance policy is exchanged under section 1035?
In a qualifying exchange, the loss is not recognized. Section 1035(a) provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the listed contracts, and the new contract's basis is then set by section 1031(d), the same as the old contract's basis with the adjustments the statute lists.
Can a loss on a 1035 exchange be deducted on a federal tax return?
Sections 1035 and 1031 do not provide for deducting it at the exchange; both state that the loss is not recognized. Whether any loss on a later surrender or lapse of the new contract has a tax effect is not stated in these provisions and depends on the facts of the contracts, which call for review by a qualified tax professional.
Does a 1035 exchange preserve the basis of a policy or annuity with a loss?
Section 1031(d) provides that the basis of the contract received "shall be the same as that of the property exchanged," decreased by money received and adjusted for any gain or loss recognized. When nothing is received and nothing is recognized, 26 C.F.R. § 1.1031(d)-1(a) gives the new contract the same basis as the old one, adjusted to the date of the exchange.
Does the direction of the exchange matter for an annuity with a loss?
Yes. Only the directions section 1035(a) lists come within it, and 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that section 1035 does not apply to an annuity or endowment exchanged for life insurance, or an annuity exchanged for an endowment. In those cases the regulation states that "any gain or loss shall be recognized."
Does receiving money in the exchange let the owner recognize the loss?
No. Section 1031(c) provides that even when "other property or money" is received in an otherwise qualifying exchange, "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." Money received can cause gain to be recognized under section 1031(b), and it reduces the new contract's basis under section 1031(d).
What does an owner give up by exchanging a contract with a loss?
The main trade-off is that the exchange cannot be used to recognize the economic loss at the time of the exchange. The old basis carries into the new contract under section 1031(d), and what that means later depends on the facts of both contracts.
Exchanging an Old Life Insurance Policy: MEC Status and Older Contract Terms
Exchanging an Underperforming Policy or Annuity Under Section 1035
Exchanging a High-Cost Life Insurance Policy or Annuity Under Section 1035
Exchanging a Policy or Annuity With a Gain: When the Gain Is Taxed
Changing Insurance Companies With a 1035 Exchange: The Transfer and How It Is Reported
Changing Policy Type With a 1035 Exchange: Which Contract Changes Section 1035 Allows
