POLICY SITUATIONS

Exchanging an Underperforming Policy or Annuity Under Section 1035

IMMEDIATE ANSWER

A 1035 exchange moves a struggling contract's value as it stands. It recognizes no gain or loss, and section 1031(d) ties the new basis to the old contract's.

WHAT TO REVIEW

Facts like these can change how an exchange is treated. Review the whole transaction, and use the 1035 Exchange Assessment Calculator to list the issues to investigate.

What Section 1035 Does, and Does Not Do, for a Struggling Contract

Exchanging an underperforming policy or annuity under Section 1035 moves the contract's value as it stands into a new contract. The exchange does not restore lost value or change how a contract performs. Where the value has fallen below what was paid in, Section 1035(a) provides that no gain or loss is recognized, and Section 1031(d) carries the old basis over.

The people who usually ask this question own an underperforming life insurance policy, an underperforming universal life policy, an underperforming IUL (indexed universal life policy) or an underperforming annuity. Their contract has grown slowly, has lost value, or may be at risk of lapse. This page explains how the federal exchange rules treat that situation. It also explains what a surrender would mean instead. How a contract has performed, how it credits interest and whether it may lapse are facts held by the insurance companies, not federal tax rules. Those facts are confirmed with both carriers. The general Section 1035 rules and the broader decision framework appear on other pages of 1035 Exchange, including its overview of Section 1035 exchange rules.

Why an Underperforming Contract Raises Distinct Section 1035 Issues

A contract that disappoints its owner is not a special category under the Internal Revenue Code. On this page, "underperforming" means a contract whose cash value or account value is less than expected, has grown more slowly than projected, or has fallen below the owner's investment in the contract.

The investment in the contract is the tax measure of what the owner has put in. Section 72(e)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code defines it as "the aggregate amount of premiums or other consideration paid for the contract before such date, minus ... the aggregate amount received under the contract before such date, to the extent that such amount was excludable from gross income." Put simply, it is the premiums paid, less amounts already received that were excludable from gross income. Basis is the related tax term for the owner's cost in property. The basis rule for an exchange appears in section 1031(d).

When the cash value sits below the investment in the contract, the contract is in a loss position. That position raises a question a well-performing contract does not raise: what the exchange rules do with value that is gone. The statute's answer is the same whether a contract has done well or poorly. Section 1035(a) provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the listed contracts. Section 1031(d) sets the basis of the contract received. The rules do not change with performance. The arithmetic does change, because the basis carried forward can exceed the value carried forward.

An underperforming universal life or indexed universal life policy can raise a second issue. If the account value cannot support the policy's cost of insurance charges, the policy may face lapse. Whether and when that happens depends on the contract's terms and the carrier's administration. It is not a tax rule.

How an Underperforming Contract's Value and Basis Move in a Section 1035 Exchange

Section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" four kinds of contract pairs:

  • "a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract";
  • "a contract of endowment insurance (A) for another contract of endowment insurance which provides for regular payments beginning at a date not later than the date payments would have begun under the contract exchanged, or (B) for an annuity contract, or (C) for a qualified long-term care insurance contract";
  • "an annuity contract for an annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract"; or
  • "a qualified long-term care insurance contract for a qualified long-term care insurance contract."

The list runs in one direction. The Treasury regulation at 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that "This section and section 1035 do not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract. In the case of such exchanges, any gain or loss shall be recognized." An owner of an underperforming annuity therefore cannot move its value into a life insurance policy under Section 1035.

The regulation also limits who the contracts cover. It provides that section 1035 "does not apply to such exchanges if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured." For annuities, it adds that the exchange "is limited to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the contract received in exchange as under the original contract." An obligee is the person to whom the insurer owes the contract's payments.

The exchange carries the contract's current value. That is the cash value or account value the contract actually has, not a value it once had or was projected to reach. A loss in value is not repaired by the exchange. Any later growth depends on the terms of the new contract and how its carrier credits it.

Basis follows a different rule. Section 1031(d) provides that where property is acquired on an exchange described in section 1035(a), "the basis shall be the same as that of the property exchanged, decreased in the amount of any money received by the taxpayer and increased in the amount of gain or decreased in the amount of loss to the taxpayer that was recognized on such exchange." The statute ties the new contract's basis to the old contract's basis, not to its cash value. In a contract-for-contract exchange with no money received and nothing recognized, those words leave the basis unadjusted. That is true even when the basis exceeds the value transferred.

Where money or other property is also received, section 1031(c) provides that "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized."

The method of the exchange also matters. An exchange is generally carried out as a direct exchange or an assignment of the contract, either between two companies or within the same company. The IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 describe an exchange that "occurs within the same company." They also refer readers to Rev. Rul. 2007-24 for certain transactions that do not qualify as exchanges under section 1035. The site's page on a direct transfer in an exchange covers the method in more detail. Whether the new contract will perform better than the old one is not a tax question. It is a set of facts confirmed with both carriers.

Tax Consequences When the Contract's Value Is Below Basis

The statute supplies the core consequence. In an exchange within Section 1035(a), "No gain or loss shall be recognized." Where an otherwise qualifying exchange also involves money or other property, section 1031(c) adds that "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." Section 1031(d) then sets the new contract's basis by reference to the old contract's basis. How a particular loss is treated for tax beyond those words depends on the facts of both contracts.

A surrender is a different transaction. When an owner surrenders a contract instead of exchanging it, Section 1035 does not apply. The amount received is governed by section 72(e). Section 72(e)(5)(E) reaches "any amount received under a contract on its complete surrender, redemption, or maturity." In those cases section 72(e)(5)(A) provides that the amount "shall be included in gross income, but only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract." When the surrender value is below the investment in the contract, the tax treatment of the difference is not settled by those words alone. The site's comparison of an exchange versus a surrender sets the two side by side.

Money or other property, sometimes called boot, changes the result. Section 1031(b) provides that where an exchange would be within section 1035(a) but for the receipt of "other property or money," the gain "shall be recognized, but in an amount not in excess of the sum of such money and the fair market value of such other property." The regulation at 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that such an exchange "does not come within the provisions of section 1035."

A policy loan is a separate point. The IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 state that "the cancellation of a contract loan at the time of the exchange may be taxable and reportable on a separate Form 1099-R." No other federal statement on this page addresses how a loan at the exchange is taxed. The site's page on an exchange with a policy loan explains the issue further.

Modified endowment contract status can follow the exchange. Section 7702A(a) defines a modified endowment contract as a contract that meets the federal definition of a life insurance contract and that either "(A) is entered into on or after June 21, 1988, and (B) fails to meet the 7-pay test of subsection (b)," or "is received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1) or this paragraph." A life insurance contract received in exchange for a modified endowment contract is therefore itself one. An annuity received in exchange is not, because it is not a life insurance contract. Under section 7702A(c)(3)(A), a "material change" makes the contract "a new contract entered into on the day on which such material change takes effect" for the 7-pay test.

Several of these points turn on facts this page cannot know. Policy loans, ownership or insured changes, partial exchanges, modified endowment contract status, transaction sequencing and the tax treatment of a loss each need individual review of the contracts involved, by the insurers and a qualified tax professional.

For reporting, the IRS instructions direct that an exchange reportable on Form 1099-R shows "the total value of the contract in box 1, -0- (zero) in box 2a, the total premiums paid in box 5, and code 6 in box 7a." Code 6 indicates "the tax-free exchange of life insurance, annuity, long-term care insurance, or endowment contracts under section 1035," in the instructions' words. Under the instructions' conditions, reporting is not required for certain exchanges within the same company.

Have Questions About Your Policy?

Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!

Structuring Issues Specific to an Underperforming Contract

Frustration with a contract can push an owner toward taking the money out first and buying something new later. That sequence is a surrender followed by a purchase, not an exchange of one contract for another. The amount received on the surrender falls under section 72(e). A contract-for-contract exchange is generally carried out as a direct exchange or assignment of the original contract. The IRS instructions point to Rev. Rul. 2007-24 for transactions that do not qualify.

The same-insured and same-obligee conditions in 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 apply however the contract has performed. A change in owner or insured made alongside the exchange is one of the points that depends on the facts of both contracts.

A partial exchange moves only part of an annuity's value. For partial exchanges of annuity contracts, the IRS instructions refer readers to Rev. Proc. 2011-38 "for more information." How that guidance applies to a particular underperforming annuity depends on the contracts and the transaction.

Surrender charges are amounts an insurer may deduct when value leaves a contract. Where they apply, they reduce the value that moves into the new contract. Their existence, size and schedule are carrier facts that vary by contract. They are confirmed with both carriers. The site's page on surrender charges and exchanges explains what the tax rules do and do not cover.

Loans add another layer to an underperforming universal life or IUL policy. Under the IRS instructions, the cancellation of a contract loan at the exchange "may be taxable and reportable on a separate Form 1099-R."

Order matters as well. A withdrawal taken before an exchange, or after it, is an amount received under a contract and falls under section 72(e). Its effect depends on the timing and on the contracts.

State replacement and suitability rules govern how one insurance contract replaces another. Those rules vary by state, and the carriers handle the replacement paperwork. They are not federal tax rules. Timing of the transfer also varies by carrier and contract and is confirmed with both carriers.

Hypothetical: Exchanging a Universal Life Policy Whose Cash Value Has Fallen Below Basis

This example is hypothetical. It uses round figures and does not represent any reader's contract or result.

Assumptions:

  • An owner holds a universal life policy and has paid $80,000 in premiums.
  • No amounts have been received under the policy, so the investment in the contract is $80,000. For this example, the policy's basis is also taken as $80,000.
  • The current cash value is $60,000.
  • There is no policy loan, no surrender charge and no money or other property received.
  • The new contract is a life insurance contract on the same insured, issued by direct exchange.

Step 1: loss position. $80,000 basis − $60,000 cash value = $20,000 below basis.

Step 2: value transferred. The new contract receives the cash value as it stands: $60,000.

Step 3: basis in the new contract. Section 1031(d) makes the basis "the same as that of the property exchanged," adjusted for money received and for gain or loss recognized. With no money and nothing recognized: $80,000 + $0 − $0 = $80,000.

Step 4: recognition. Section 1035(a) provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange." The $20,000 difference is not recognized in the exchange.

A hypothetical surrender looks different. Suppose the same owner surrendered for $60,000 instead. Section 72(e)(5)(A) includes an amount in gross income "only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract": $60,000 − $80,000 leaves no excess. How the $20,000 shortfall is treated for tax is not stated by those words and depends on the facts.

Actual outcomes depend on the facts of the contracts involved.

Questions to Ask Before Exchanging an Underperforming Contract

These questions are facts to gather, not steps to take:

  • What is the contract's current cash value or account value?
  • What is the owner's investment in the contract, based on premiums paid and amounts previously received tax-free?
  • Is the contract in a loss position, with cash value below basis?
  • Is there an outstanding policy loan, and what is its balance? Treatment of a loan at the exchange depends on the facts.
  • Is the proposed pairing a direction listed in Section 1035(a), and not one that 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 excludes?
  • Will the transaction be a direct exchange or assignment of the contract, rather than a surrender followed by a new purchase?
  • Do the contracts relate to the same insured, and, for annuities, the same obligee or obligees?
  • What surrender charges, if any, apply to the existing contract? This is a carrier fact, confirmed with both carriers.
  • Could the new contract be a modified endowment contract under section 7702A?
  • What replacement requirements apply in the owner's state? These vary by state, and the carriers handle the paperwork.
  • What do both carriers say about crediting, charges and lapse under the old and new contracts?

Alternatives to a Section 1035 Exchange for an Underperforming Contract

Each alternative carries its own federal rules, and none is described here as preferable.

Surrender. A complete surrender is an amount received under the contract. Under section 72(e)(5)(E) and (A), that amount is included in gross income "only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract." Treatment of a shortfall below the investment in the contract depends on the facts.

Keeping the contract. Keeping the contract involves no exchange, so the exchange requirements do not arise. How the contract performs from here, and whether it may lapse, are carrier facts.

Reduced paid-up or extended term options. Some policies offer these as contract features. They change the existing policy rather than exchanging one contract for another. Their availability and terms vary by contract and carrier.

A loan under the existing contract. A loan outside any exchange is a separate matter. Section 72(e)(4)(A) treats a loan under a contract to which it applies as "an amount not received as an annuity." For most life insurance contracts, however, section 72(e)(5)(C) keeps the older rule that does not apply (4)(A). For a modified endowment contract, section 72(e)(10) applies paragraphs (2)(B) and (4)(A). Section 72(v) adds a tax equal to "10 percent of the portion of such amount which is includible in gross income." It does not apply to distributions made on or after age 59½, attributable to disability, or that are part of a series of substantially equal periodic payments.

Comparing these paths turns on the facts of the contracts, the owner's tax situation and the carriers' terms. This page describes the rules. It does not identify a choice.

What to Check with the Exchange

A policyowner in this position typically gathers the following before an exchange begins:

  • A current statement showing the cash value or account value.
  • Records of every premium paid and any amounts received that were excludable from gross income, which bear on the investment in the contract under section 72(e)(6).
  • Confirmation from both carriers of the exchange direction, the direct exchange or assignment method, and any surrender charges.
  • Confirmation that the same-insured and same-obligee conditions of 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 are met.
  • Any loan balance, and the carrier's description of how it will be handled at the exchange.
  • The state replacement forms the carriers require, which vary by state.
  • A look at whether the new contract could be a modified endowment contract under section 7702A.

Whether a particular exchange meets the requirements of Section 1035 is confirmed with both carriers and a qualified tax professional.

Have Questions About Your Policy?

Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!

FREQUENT QUESTIONS

Questions & answers

Does a 1035 exchange fix an underperforming life insurance policy?

No, the exchange itself does not change performance. It moves the contract's current value into a new contract. Whether the new contract credits or charges differently is a carrier fact, confirmed with both carriers.

What happens to basis when a policy that has lost value is exchanged?

Section 1031(d) provides that the basis of a contract acquired in a section 1035(a) exchange "shall be the same as that of the property exchanged." That basis is adjusted for money received and for gain or loss recognized. The rule refers to the old contract's basis, not its cash value.

Is a loss recognized when an underperforming policy is exchanged under Section 1035?

Section 1035(a) provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the contracts it lists. Where money or other property is also received, section 1031(c) provides that "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." How a particular loss is treated beyond those words depends on the facts.

Can an annuity be converted to life insurance in a 1035 exchange?

No. The regulation at 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that section 1035 does not apply to "the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract." It adds that "any gain or loss shall be recognized" in such exchanges.

How does exchanging an underperforming annuity differ from surrendering it?

An exchange within Section 1035(a) recognizes no gain or loss. A complete surrender is governed by section 72(e), which includes the amount received in gross income "only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract." Treatment of any shortfall below that investment depends on the facts.

Does a policy loan affect an exchange of an underperforming IUL?

It can. The IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 state that "the cancellation of a contract loan at the time of the exchange may be taxable and reportable on a separate Form 1099-R." Whether and how a particular loan is taxed depends on the facts of the contracts.

Can an underperforming universal life policy at risk of lapse still be exchanged?

Section 1035(a) does not list lapse risk as a condition. The exchange still has to fit a listed direction, relate to the same insured, and be made by direct exchange or assignment. Only the cash value that remains moves to the new contract. Lapse status and timing are carrier facts.

Will the new contract be a modified endowment contract?

It may be. Section 7702A(a)(2) includes a life insurance contract "which is received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1) or this paragraph." Otherwise status turns on the June 21, 1988 date condition and the 7-pay test.

This content is general educational information, not individualized tax, legal, insurance or financial advice. Contract terms and transaction facts require independent review.
PRIMARY / AUTHORITATIVE SOURCES

Remain Life Insurance Services, LLC