Exchanging a High-Cost Life Insurance Policy or Annuity Under Section 1035
Section 1035 does not test a contract's internal costs. See how basis carryover, gain, money received and MEC status work when a high-cost contract is exchanged.
Facts like these can change how an exchange is treated. Review the whole transaction, and use the 1035 Exchange Assessment Calculator to list the issues to investigate.
Published October 6, 2026 · Updated October 9, 2026
What Section 1035 Provides When a Policy's Costs Are High
A high-cost life insurance policy or annuity can be exchanged under Section 1035 on the same terms as any other contract. The statute looks at contract type, exchange direction and who the contract covers, not at how expensive the old contract is. High internal charges change the economics and the gain involved, not the qualification test.
Section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the contracts it lists. Owners who feel their annuity fees are too high, or who hold an expensive life insurance policy and are thinking about whether to replace it, often ask how that rule fits their situation. This 1035 Exchange page explains how high internal costs interact with the exchange rules: basis carryover, gain, money received, modified endowment contract status and structuring. It does not judge whether any contract's costs are high or low, compares no product's fees and does not advise whether to exchange.
Why the Cost Level of an Existing Contract Raises Exchange Issues
"Cost" here means the charges a contract deducts internally over time, not the premium itself. FINRA Rule 2330, a rule of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority that governs FINRA members and their associated persons when they recommend deferred variable annuities, lists examples such as "mortality and expense fees; investment advisory fees; potential charges for and features of riders," along with surrender periods and surrender charges. Administrative charges belong in the same category. Each of these reduces the contract's cash value.
That reduction matters because of the investment in the contract. Section 72(e)(6) defines the investment in the contract as "the aggregate amount of premiums or other consideration paid for the contract," minus amounts received earlier to the extent they were excludable from gross income. It is commonly called basis. Charges reduce cash value, but they do not reduce the premiums paid. A contract with heavy charges may therefore have a cash value close to, or even below, its basis.
The reverse can also be true. If investment growth has outpaced the charges, the cash value may still exceed basis, and the contract holds gain. That gain is what the exchange rules address, so it bears directly on whether the deferral Section 1035 describes has any practical effect.
A high fee variable annuity is a common example. When a FINRA member recommends exchanging one deferred variable annuity for another, Rule 2330 requires consideration of whether the customer "would incur a surrender charge, be subject to the commencement of a new surrender period, lose existing benefits," or "be subject to increased fees or charges," and whether the customer "has had another deferred variable annuity exchange within the preceding 36 months." That rule binds the recommending firm, not the tax result.
None of this changes the federal requirements. Section 1035(a) and 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 still set the permitted directions, the same-insured rule and the same-obligee rule. Surrender charges on the existing contract vary by carrier and contract and are confirmed with both carriers. State replacement and suitability rules also vary by state, and the carriers handle the replacement paperwork.
How High Costs Affect the Exchange Mechanics
Basis is where cost first shows up in the mechanics. Section 1031(d), which 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 says governs basis in a Section 1035 exchange, provides that "the basis shall be the same as that of the property exchanged, decreased in the amount of any money received by the taxpayer and increased in the amount of gain or decreased in the amount of loss to the taxpayer that was recognized on such exchange." In plain terms, the new contract generally inherits the old contract's basis, adjusted only as that sentence describes. This page computes no reader's basis.
Gain depends on the relationship between cash value and basis:
- Cash value well above basis. Gain exists, and in an exchange that meets Section 1035(a), no gain is recognized at the exchange. The gain is carried into the new contract through the carryover basis.
- Cash value near basis. Gain is small, so there is less to defer. The comparison with a surrender is then driven mainly by non-tax factors such as surrender charges and contract features. The site's page on 1035 exchange versus surrender covers that comparison.
- Cash value below basis. The contract holds a loss. How a particular loss is treated is not settled by the exchange statute's words alone.
The exchange direction must be one Section 1035(a) lists. In its words, that includes "a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract"; an endowment contract for another endowment contract "which provides for regular payments beginning at a date not later than the date payments would have begun under the contract exchanged," or for an annuity contract or a qualified long-term care insurance contract; "an annuity contract for an annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract"; and "a qualified long-term care insurance contract for a qualified long-term care insurance contract."
The list runs one way. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that the section does "not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract. In the case of such exchanges, any gain or loss shall be recognized." An owner moving out of a high-fee annuity into life insurance is outside Section 1035. The site's page on exchanges Section 1035 excludes lists the others.
The same regulation adds two conditions. Section 1035 "does not apply to such exchanges if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured," and an annuity-for-annuity exchange "is limited to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the contract received in exchange as under the original contract." Carrier forms, procedures and surrender-charge schedules vary by carrier and are confirmed with both carriers.
Tax Consequences When a High-Cost Contract Is Exchanged
When the exchange meets the statute, the consequence is the one Section 1035(a) states: "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the listed contracts. That is tax deferral, not elimination. The gain stays embedded in the new contract through the carryover basis.
Money or other property received. Sometimes an exchange delivers a new contract plus cash. Section 1031(b) applies when an exchange would be within section 1035(a) except that the taxpayer also receives "other property or money." Then "the gain, if any, to the recipient shall be recognized, but in an amount not in excess of the sum of such money and the fair market value of such other property." This money or other property is often called boot. Section 1031(c) adds that in such an exchange "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 notes that such an exchange "does not come within the provisions of section 1035," which is why it turns to section 1031(b) and (c). For a high-cost contract with little gain, the recognized amount is capped by the gain itself, as section 1031(b) says "the gain, if any."
Policy loans. An outstanding loan against the old contract raises its own question at the exchange. The site's page on exchanges with a policy loan covers that topic. This page states no rule for how a loan at the exchange is taxed.
Modified endowment contract status. A modified endowment contract, or MEC, is a life insurance contract funded faster than federal law allows for the most favourable distribution treatment. Section 7702A(a) defines it as any contract meeting the federal tax definition of a life insurance contract "(1) which— (A) is entered into on or after June 21, 1988, and (B) fails to meet the 7-pay test of subsection (b), or (2) which is received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1) or this paragraph." A high-cost life policy may already be a MEC. A life insurance contract received in exchange for a MEC is itself a MEC, because it meets that life insurance definition. An annuity contract received in exchange does not meet that definition, so it is not a MEC under section 7702A.
For a MEC, section 72(e)(10) provides that paragraphs (2)(B) and (4)(A) of section 72(e) apply. Amounts received before the annuity starting date are included in income first to the extent of income on the contract, and loans, assignments and pledges are "treated as received under the contract as an amount not received as an annuity." Section 72(v) adds a tax equal to "10 percent of the portion of such amount which is includible in gross income," except for distributions made on or after age 59½, distributions attributable to disability, or a series of substantially equal periodic payments.
Losses. The statutes speak to losses only in their own words: section 1035(a), "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of," and section 1031(c), "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." Policy loans at the exchange, MEC status and the treatment of any particular loss all need individual review of the contracts involved, by the insurers and a qualified tax professional.
Have Questions About Your Policy?
Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!
Structuring Issues Specific to High-Cost Contract Exchanges
How the value moves is as important as where it goes. An exchange is generally carried out as a direct exchange or an assignment of the contract. A surrender of the old contract followed by a new purchase with the proceeds is a different transaction. The site's page on direct transfers in an exchange explains the distinction.
A partial exchange moves only part of a contract's value. Its basis and MEC questions, and any holding periods, are covered on the site's own partial exchange page and depend on the facts of both contracts.
Ownership and insured changes also need attention. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 excludes exchanges where the policies "to not relate to the same insured," and limits annuity exchanges to the same obligees. Changing the owner or insured near an exchange can raise further federal questions, including transfer-for-value issues, that turn on the specific facts.
Order matters as well. Transaction sequencing means the order in which steps occur, such as repaying a loan, changing a beneficiary, taking a withdrawal or assigning the contract. It can affect whether the transaction is an exchange at all. Carrier forms, procedures and timing vary by carrier and contract and are confirmed with both carriers.
Hypothetical Example: Exchanging a High-Fee Variable Annuity
This example is hypothetical. It uses round figures and does not represent any reader's contract or result.
Assumptions:
- An owner paid $80,000 in premiums into a nonqualified variable annuity and received nothing from it before. The investment in the contract is $80,000.
- The current cash value is $100,000, after years of high internal charges.
- There is no outstanding loan. The owner, annuitant and obligee stay the same.
- The contract moves by direct assignment into another annuity contract, and no money or other property is received.
Step 1: gain in the contract. $100,000 cash value − $80,000 investment in the contract = $20,000 gain.
Step 2: the exchange. Annuity-for-annuity is a direction section 1035(a)(3) lists. If the exchange meets the statute and regulation, section 1035(a) provides that no gain is recognized on the $20,000.
Step 3: basis in the new contract. Under section 1031(d), the basis is the same as the old contract's. No money was received and no gain or loss was recognized, so the new contract's basis is $80,000. The $20,000 gain remains inside the new contract.
Contrast with a surrender. On a complete surrender, section 72(e)(5)(E) and (A) apply, and the amount is included in gross income to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract. That gives $100,000 − $80,000 = $20,000 includible. Section 72(q) may add a 10 percent additional tax on the includible portion of certain annuity distributions, subject to exceptions the statute provides. Any surrender charge would change these figures, and charges vary by contract.
MEC note. If the old contract had been a MEC life insurance policy exchanged for another life policy, the new policy would also be a MEC under section 7702A(a)(2), and sections 72(e)(10) and 72(v) would govern its distributions. Because this example involves annuities, which do not meet the federal life insurance definition, the MEC definition does not reach either contract. Actual outcomes depend on the facts of the contracts involved.
Questions to Ask About a High-Cost Contract Before Exchanging
An owner of a costly contract and the owner's advisers typically work through questions like these:
- What is the investment in the contract, what is the current cash value, and is there gain or a loss?
- Is the existing contract a modified endowment contract under section 7702A, and would the destination contract meet the federal life insurance definition and therefore also be one?
- Is there an outstanding policy loan, and what would happen to it at the exchange?
- Is the intended direction one section 1035(a) lists, or is it annuity to life insurance, which 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 places outside the section?
- Will any money or other property be received, and how much gain would section 1031(b) then recognize?
- Do surrender charges apply on the old contract, and does a new surrender period begin on the new one? Both carriers confirm these.
- Will the value move by direct exchange or assignment rather than a surrender and repurchase?
- Do the same insured and the same obligee carry over?
- What benefits or riders on the old contract would end with it?
Potential Alternatives to Exchanging a High-Cost Contract
An exchange is one path among several. The tax characteristics of each are described here without recommending any. The answer turns on the facts of the contracts involved and the owner's circumstances.
Surrender. The owner receives the cash surrender value. Under section 72(e)(5)(E), any amount over the investment in the contract is included in gross income, and no section 1035 deferral applies. How any loss on surrender is treated depends on the facts. The site's page on surrender charges and exchanges addresses the charge side.
Keeping the existing contract. The owner keeps the contract and its cost structure. No exchange questions arise, and this page does not evaluate whether doing so is preferable.
Partial exchange. Part of the value may be exchanged and the rest left in place. This raises its own basis and MEC questions, covered on the site's partial exchange page.
A loan under a life insurance contract. A loan taken outside any exchange is a separate matter. For a life insurance contract that is not a MEC, section 72(e)(5)(C) generally keeps the existing rules, under which the loan-as-distribution rule of section 72(e)(4)(A) does not apply. For a MEC, section 72(e)(10) applies that rule and section 72(v) may add its 10 percent tax, subject to its exceptions. The effect on a particular contract depends on its terms and status.
Life settlements, viatical settlements and sales of a policy to a third party are covered elsewhere and not here.
What to Check with the Exchange
Several facts and confirmations are typically gathered before an exchange of a high-cost contract begins:
- The existing contract's current cash value, investment in the contract and any loan balance, from the carrier's most recent statement.
- The existing contract's MEC status, confirmed with the carrier, because a life contract received in exchange for a MEC is itself one under section 7702A(a).
- That the direction is one section 1035(a) lists and not one 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 excludes.
- That both carriers will process the transaction as a direct exchange or assignment.
- Surrender charges, exchange forms and procedures, all of which vary by carrier and contract.
- Whether any money or other property will be received, and how much, given section 1031(b).
- That the same insured and same obligee requirements of 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 are met.
Ownership or insured changes, policy loans, partial exchanges, MEC status and transaction sequencing all need individual review of the contracts involved, by the insurers and a qualified tax professional.
Have Questions About Your Policy?
Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!
Questions & answers
Does the cost level of a life insurance policy affect whether a Section 1035 exchange qualifies?
No, the statute sets no cost test. Section 1035(a) and 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 look at contract type, exchange direction, the same insured and the same obligee. High costs affect cash value, gain and the economics, not the statutory conditions.
What happens to basis when a high-cost policy is exchanged under Section 1035?
The new contract generally takes the old contract's basis. Section 1031(d) provides that the basis "shall be the same as that of the property exchanged," decreased by any money received and adjusted for any gain or loss recognized. Computing a specific contract's basis depends on its premium and distribution history.
If an annuity has high fees and low cash value, is there still a tax benefit to exchanging it?
The tax effect of an exchange is the deferral of gain, so it depends on how much gain exists. If high fees have pulled cash value close to or below basis, there may be little or no gain to defer. The comparison with a surrender then rests largely on charges and contract features.
Can a high-fee variable annuity be exchanged for a different annuity under Section 1035?
Section 1035(a)(3) lists "an annuity contract for an annuity contract," so the direction is permitted. The same-obligee and same-insured conditions in 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 still apply, and the value generally moves by direct exchange or assignment. Whether a particular exchange qualifies is confirmed with both carriers and a qualified tax professional.
If an existing life insurance policy is already a modified endowment contract, what happens on an exchange?
A life insurance contract received in exchange for a MEC is itself a MEC under section 7702A(a)(2). Sections 72(e)(10) and 72(v) then govern its distributions and loans. An annuity received in exchange does not meet the federal life insurance definition and is not a MEC under section 7702A.
What is boot, and how does it affect an exchange of a high-cost policy?
Boot is money or other property received alongside the new contract. Section 1031(b) recognizes gain up to the money plus the fair market value of the other property, and section 1031(c) recognizes no loss. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 says such an exchange "does not come within the provisions of section 1035." When a high-cost contract has little gain, the gain itself limits what can be recognized.
What are the tax consequences of surrendering an expensive life insurance policy instead of exchanging it?
On a complete surrender, section 72(e) generally includes in gross income the amount by which the proceeds exceed the investment in the contract. No section 1035 deferral applies. How any loss on surrender is treated depends on the facts.
Exchanging an Old Life Insurance Policy: MEC Status and Older Contract Terms
Exchanging an Underperforming Policy or Annuity Under Section 1035
Exchanging a Policy or Annuity With a Gain: When the Gain Is Taxed
Exchanging a Policy or Annuity Worth Less Than You Paid
Changing Insurance Companies With a 1035 Exchange: The Transfer and How It Is Reported
Changing Policy Type With a 1035 Exchange: Which Contract Changes Section 1035 Allows
