COMPARISONS AND DECISIONS

1035 Exchange vs Borrowing Against the Policy: How the Two Paths Compare

SHORT ANSWER

Compares a 1035 exchange with a policy loan under federal rules: when gain is recognized, how basis carries over, and what each path keeps or gives up.

OPTION A1035 exchange
VERSUS
OPTION BPolicy loan

Short Answer: Exchanging the Contract or Borrowing From It

A 1035 exchange gives up the existing contract for a new one, and federal law provides that no gain or loss is recognized on a listed exchange. A policy loan keeps the existing contract in force and borrows against its cash value. Its tax treatment depends on whether the contract is life insurance, an annuity or a modified endowment contract.

Owners of permanent life insurance or annuity contracts often weigh a policy loan or 1035 exchange when they want either cash from the contract or a different contract. The two paths do different things. One replaces the contract. The other uses the contract's value while keeping it. Neither path is preferable in every case, and the outcome depends on the facts of the contracts involved. 1035 Exchange covers section 1035 exchange questions, and this page sets the two paths side by side.

At-a-Glance Comparison: 1035 Exchange vs Policy Loan

The table below is a summary. The sections that follow give the full explanation.

Criterion1035 ExchangePolicy Loan
Tax timingSection 1035(a): "No gain or loss shall be recognized" on a listed exchangeDepends on the contract type and MEC status under section 72(e)
Cost basisCarries over under section 1031(d), in the statute's wordsStays with the existing contract
Existing guaranteesThe original contract ends, and the new contract's terms governThe original contract and its terms remain while it stays in force
Surrender chargesDepend on the original contract's terms; confirm with the insurers involvedDepend on the contract's terms if it later lapses or is surrendered; confirm with the insurer
New surrender periodThe new contract has its own terms; varies by contractNo new contract is issued
Death benefitSet by the new contract's termsAn outstanding loan generally reduces the amount payable, under the contract's terms
LiquidityGoverned by the new contract's termsCash is drawn now, and the balance stays under the contract's terms

Tax Timing: When Gain Is Recognized

On the exchange side, section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the listed contracts. The list covers:

  • a life insurance contract exchanged for another life insurance contract, or for an endowment, annuity or qualified long-term care insurance contract;
  • an endowment contract exchanged for another endowment contract with payments beginning no later, or for an annuity or a qualified long-term care insurance contract;
  • an annuity contract exchanged for an annuity or a qualified long-term care insurance contract;
  • a qualified long-term care insurance contract exchanged for another one.

In this setting, gain means the amount by which the contract's value exceeds what was paid into it. Under section 1035(a), that gain is deferred, not erased.

Treasury Regulation 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 adds conditions. It says section 1035 "does not apply to such exchanges if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured." For annuities, it limits the rule "to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the contract received in exchange as under the original contract." The regulation also says section 1035 does "not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract." In those cases, "any gain or loss shall be recognized."

The exchange itself is a direct exchange or an assignment of the contract. It can take place between two companies or within the same company.

A policy loan follows different rules. Section 72(e)(4)(A) treats a loan under a contract as an amount "received under the contract as an amount not received as an annuity." For a life insurance contract that is not a modified endowment contract, however, section 72(e)(5)(C) applies the older rules. Under those rules, paragraph (4)(A) "shall not apply." For an annuity contract, section 72(e)(4)(A) itself applies, so a loan is treated as a distribution. A modified endowment contract (MEC) is a life insurance contract that is taxed more like an annuity on distributions. Section 72(e)(10) applies paragraph (4)(A) to a MEC.

One point connects the two paths. The IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 state that "the cancellation of a contract loan at the time of the exchange may be taxable and reportable on a separate Form 1099-R."

Several topics on this page need individual review by the insurers involved and a qualified tax professional:

  • whether and how a loan is taxed;
  • MEC status;
  • ownership or insured changes;
  • partial exchanges;
  • the order in which a loan and an exchange take place.

Cost Basis: What Happens to the Investment in the Contract

Cost basis is the owner's after-tax stake in the contract. Section 72(e)(6) calls it the "investment in the contract" and defines it as "the aggregate amount of premiums or other consideration paid for the contract," minus amounts received under the contract that were excludable from gross income.

In an exchange, 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that basis "shall be governed by section 1031(d)." Section 1031(d) provides that "the basis shall be the same as that of the property exchanged, decreased in the amount of any money received by the taxpayer and increased in the amount of gain or decreased in the amount of loss to the taxpayer that was recognized on such exchange."

With a policy loan, section 72(e)(4)(A) states that the loan rule "shall not apply for purposes of determining investment in the contract," except that the investment is increased by any amount included in gross income because of it. The basis stays with the existing contract. Basis records matter for any later surrender or exchange, and 1035 Exchange covers them on its other pages.

Existing Guarantees: What Each Path Preserves or Gives Up

Guarantees are features the contract itself promises, such as a guaranteed death benefit or a guaranteed minimum interest rate. In an exchange, the original contract is given up. Its guarantees end with it, and only the new contract's terms apply from then on.

A loan leaves the original contract in place. Its terms continue while the contract stays in force, which means it has not lapsed and has not been surrendered. Guarantee terms vary by contract and are confirmed with the insurers involved. Any change of owner or insured that comes with an exchange depends on the facts of both contracts.

Surrender Charges: How Each Path Interacts With Them

A surrender charge is a fee some contracts deduct when value leaves the contract within a set period. Whether the original contract's charge applies in an exchange depends on that contract's terms, and those terms vary by insurer. More on this appears on the page about surrender charges and exchanges.

A loan is not a surrender. Whether any charge applies if the contract later lapses or is surrendered while a loan is outstanding depends on the contract's terms. No federal source sets surrender-charge amounts or schedules, so they are confirmed with the insurers involved.

New Surrender Period: The Exchange's Separate Clock

Because an exchange results in a new contract, any surrender-charge schedule is measured under the new contract's own terms. Its length and structure vary by contract and are confirmed with both insurers. The time a transfer takes also varies by insurer and contract.

A loan issues no new contract, so no new schedule begins. State replacement and suitability rules govern how a replacement is documented. These rules vary by state, and the insurers handle the replacement paperwork.

Death Benefit: How Each Path Affects the Amount Payable

After an exchange into a new life insurance contract, the death benefit is whatever the new contract provides. It may be larger, smaller or structured differently. If the new contract is an annuity, the amount payable at death follows that annuity's terms.

Under a loan, many contracts subtract the outstanding loan and accrued interest from the death benefit paid to beneficiaries. How this works depends on the contract and is confirmed with the insurer.

Have Questions About Your Policy?

Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!

Contract Features: What Transfers and What Does Not

Riders, dividend options, paid-up additions and similar features belong to the contract that provides them. Riders are optional benefits added to a contract. Paid-up additions are small amounts of extra coverage bought with dividends. In an exchange, the new contract offers only the features written into it. A loan leaves the existing features in place while the contract remains in force.

MEC status can carry into the new contract. Section 7702A(a) defines a modified endowment contract as a contract meeting the federal tax definition of a life insurance contract that either:

  • "is entered into on or after June 21, 1988, and" "fails to meet the 7-pay test of subsection (b)"; or
  • "is received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1) or this paragraph."

That definition covers life insurance contracts. An annuity received in exchange is therefore not a MEC under this definition.

The 7-pay test compares the amount paid into the contract during its first seven contract years with the premiums that would have paid up its future benefits over seven level annual payments. Under section 7702A(c)(3)(A), a "material change" makes the contract "a new contract entered into on the day on which such material change takes effect" for applying that test. How older terms carry over is covered on the page about an old life insurance policy.

Liquidity: Access to Cash Value After Each Transaction

Liquidity here means the ability to get cash out of the contract. An exchange moves value into the new contract, and access afterward follows that contract's withdrawal, loan and surrender terms.

A loan provides cash now, and the remaining value stays in the existing contract. Under many contracts, a loan may be repaid. An unpaid balance and its interest reduce both the net cash value and the death benefit. How much may be borrowed is set by the contract and confirmed with the insurer.

Policy Loans: The Federal Tax Rules That Apply

Section 72(e) treats a loan differently depending on the contract.

  • Non-MEC life insurance. Section 72(e)(5)(C) applies the older rules, under which section 72(e)(4)(A) "shall not apply." Under those rules, an amount is included in gross income "only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract."
  • Annuity. Section 72(e)(4)(A) applies directly, and a loan is treated as an amount not received as an annuity. Section 72(q) adds a 10 percent tax on the includible portion of amounts received under an annuity contract, subject to its exceptions.
  • MEC. Section 72(e)(10) provides that paragraphs (2)(B) and (4)(A) "shall apply." Under section 72(e)(2)(B), the amount is taxed first "to the extent allocable to income on the contract." Section 72(v) adds a tax "equal to 10 percent of the portion of such amount which is includible in gross income." That additional tax does not apply to distributions made on or after age 59½, distributions due to disability, or certain substantially equal periodic payments.

A loan outstanding when an exchange takes place is a separate question. Combining a loan with an exchange also raises questions about the order of the steps. The page on exchanges with policy loans covers that topic.

Long-Term Economics: How Each Path Affects the Contract Over Time

After an exchange, growth, internal charges and features come from the new contract. The deferred gain stays with that contract through the carryover basis that section 1031(d) describes.

Under a loan, interest accrues on the balance. An unpaid, growing balance reduces cash value and the death benefit. Under many contracts, the contract may lapse if the loan balance reaches the cash value. A lapse while a loan is outstanding can produce taxable income, and the amount depends on the facts of the contract. How each path develops depends on:

  • credited rates;
  • the contract's internal charges;
  • the loan interest rate;
  • whether, and when, the loan is repaid.

No federal source sets any of these.

When a 1035 Exchange May Fit

An exchange is commonly considered in these situations:

  • A different contract is the goal. The owner whose aim is a different contract type or different features may weigh an exchange, accepting that the original contract's guarantees end and that the new contract brings its own terms.
  • There is gain in the contract. An owner whose contract shows gain may compare section 1035(a) treatment with a surrender, which the page on 1035 exchange vs surrender covers.
  • Cash is not needed now. Owners in this position are often not seeking immediate cash.

Whether a given exchange falls within section 1035(a) and 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 turns on several facts: the direction of the exchange, the same insured and the same obligee.

When a Policy Loan May Fit

Owners commonly consider a loan in these situations:

  • Cash is needed, but the contract is not. The owner wants part of the cash value without surrendering or replacing the contract.
  • The existing contract is valued. The owner wants to keep the existing guarantees, riders and features.
  • Repayment is intended. The owner intends to repay the loan and limit the reduction in value.

The contract type matters a great deal here. A loan from an annuity or a MEC is treated under section 72(e)(4)(A), together with section 72(q) or section 72(v). A loan from a non-MEC life insurance contract follows section 72(e)(5).

Decision Framework: Questions to Consider Before Choosing

Before choosing whether to borrow from life insurance or exchange it, an owner commonly works through these questions:

  • Does the owner need cash now, or is the goal a different contract?
  • Is the existing contract life insurance, an annuity or a modified endowment contract?
  • Does the existing contract already carry a loan balance?
  • Would the owner use the cash value temporarily, through a loan, or move it permanently into a new contract through an exchange?
  • What surrender charges apply to the existing contract, according to the insurer?
  • What guarantees and riders does the existing contract carry, and would any replacement contract offer them?

Each answer depends on the facts of the specific contracts and is confirmed with the insurers involved and a qualified tax professional.

Example Scenarios (Hypothetical)

Hypothetical Example A: Exchange path.

Assumptions: a life insurance contract that is not a MEC, investment in the contract of $50,000 and cash value of $80,000. The contract is exchanged for another life insurance contract, with the same insured and no loan.

  1. Gain in the contract: $80,000 − $50,000 = $30,000.
  2. If the exchange falls within section 1035(a), "No gain or loss shall be recognized" on it.
  3. Under section 1031(d), basis is "the same as that of the property exchanged." The new contract starts with a basis of $50,000.

Hypothetical Example B: Loan path.

Assumptions: the same contract, not a MEC, kept in force. The owner borrows $20,000.

  1. Section 72(e)(5)(C) applies, so section 72(e)(4)(A) does not treat the loan as a distribution.
  2. Net cash value before interest: $80,000 − $20,000 = $60,000.
  3. If the loan is not repaid, interest is added to the $20,000 balance. That reduces the net cash value and the death benefit further, under the contract's terms.

These examples use round figures, assume no interest rate, credited rate or charge, and represent no reader's result.

Questions to Ask the Insurers and a Tax Professional

  • Is the existing contract a modified endowment contract?
  • Does it carry an outstanding loan, and how would that loan be handled and reported if the contract were exchanged?
  • What surrender charges apply now, and what surrender schedule would a new contract carry?
  • Which guarantees, riders and features would end in an exchange, and what would a new contract provide?
  • What is the investment in the contract, and how would section 1031(d) carry it over?
  • Would the proposed exchange be a direct exchange or an assignment of the contract, and would any change of owner or insured be involved?

Have Questions About Your Policy?

Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!

DECISION FRAMEWORK
01What changes in the replacement contract?
02Which guarantees or features may be lost?
03Does a new surrender period apply?
04What needs professional verification?
FREQUENT QUESTIONS

Questions & answers

What is a policy loan on a life insurance contract?

A policy loan is money the insurer advances to the owner using the contract's cash value as security. The contract stays in force. Its federal tax treatment under section 72(e) depends on whether the contract is life insurance, an annuity or a modified endowment contract.

Does a policy loan trigger income tax on a non-MEC life insurance contract?

Generally, section 72(e)(5)(C) applies the older rules to a life insurance contract that is not a MEC, and under those rules section 72(e)(4)(A) "shall not apply." A MEC is the exception: section 72(e)(10) provides that for a modified endowment contract, paragraphs (2)(B) and (4)(A) "shall apply."

Does a 1035 exchange preserve the original contract's guarantees?

No. The original contract is given up, and only the new contract's terms apply. A policy loan, by contrast, leaves the original contract and its terms in place while it stays in force.

Does a policy loan reduce the death benefit?

Under many contracts, yes. The outstanding loan and accrued interest are generally subtracted from the amount paid to beneficiaries. The exact mechanics depend on the contract and are confirmed with the insurer.

What is a modified endowment contract, and why does it matter for policy loans?

Under section 7702A(a), a MEC is a contract meeting the federal tax definition of life insurance that "is entered into on or after June 21, 1988" and "fails to meet the 7-pay test," or that is received in exchange for such a contract. Under sections 72(e)(10) and 72(v), a loan from a MEC is treated as a distribution, taxed first to the extent of income on the contract, and may carry a 10 percent additional tax.

Does a 1035 exchange start a new surrender period?

An exchange results in a new contract, and any surrender schedule follows that contract's own terms. A loan issues no new contract. The length of any schedule varies by contract and is confirmed with the insurers involved.

How is the choice to borrow from life insurance or exchange it usually evaluated?

It usually turns on purpose: cash now while keeping the contract, or moving into a different contract. It also turns on the contract's type and MEC status, any existing loan, surrender charges and the guarantees at stake. The IRS instructions add that a loan cancelled at the time of an exchange "may be taxable." Whether that applies to a particular loan needs individual review.

This content is general educational information, not individualized tax, legal, insurance or financial advice. Contract terms and transaction facts require independent review.
PRIMARY / AUTHORITATIVE SOURCES

Remain Life Insurance Services, LLC