Should You Do a 1035 Exchange? Questions to Answer First
Whether a 1035 exchange fits turns on tax timing, basis carryover under section 1031(d), surrender charges, MEC status and guarantees in both contracts.
Published October 9, 2026 · Updated October 9, 2026
Short Answer: What Drives the Decision
Whether a 1035 exchange is a good idea has no single answer. It turns on facts in both contracts: the old contract's gain and cost basis, surrender charges, any modified endowment contract status, guarantees that would end, the new contract's terms, and how soon cash may be needed. Section 1035 governs only whether gain or loss is recognized.
People who ask this question usually own a life insurance policy or an annuity and have been shown a newer contract. They want to understand the 1035 exchange pros and cons before signing anything. The federal rule itself is short. Section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the contracts it lists. Everything else in the decision comes from the two contracts. This page from 1035 Exchange is general educational information. The contracts of any particular owner need individual review by the insurers involved and a qualified tax professional.
Exchange vs. Surrender at a Glance
The table sets a section 1035 exchange beside the alternative of surrendering the old contract for cash and buying a new one. A surrender is the owner's termination of a contract in return for its cash surrender value.
| Criterion | Section 1035 exchange | Surrender and replace |
|---|---|---|
| Tax timing on gain | Under 26 U.S.C. § 1035(a), "no gain or loss shall be recognized" on a listed exchange | Gain, the amount received above the investment in the contract, is included in income for the year of surrender under 26 U.S.C. § 72(e) |
| Cost basis in the new contract | Carries over under 26 U.S.C. § 1031(d) | Does not carry over. The new contract's basis starts with the premiums paid into it |
| Surrender charges on the old contract | Section 1035 does not address them. Whether they apply depends on the old contract's terms | Apply under the old contract's terms |
| New surrender period | The new contract may begin its own period under its terms | The new contract may begin its own period under its terms |
| MEC status | A life insurance contract received in exchange for a modified endowment contract is itself one under 26 U.S.C. § 7702A(a)(2) | The new contract's status is tested on its own |
| Death benefit continuity | Depends on the new contract's terms and on when the old contract ends | A gap is possible between the two steps |
| Liquidity during the transition | The value moves by direct exchange or assignment and is generally not available to the owner | Cash is in hand between the surrender and the new purchase |
Carrier forms, fees and procedures vary and are confirmed with both carriers. The table is a general framework. It is not a determination about any reader's contracts.
Tax Timing: When Gain Is Recognized
Timing is often the first of the benefits of a 1035 exchange that owners hear about. Section 1035(a) provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of":
- "a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract";
- a contract of endowment insurance "for another contract of endowment insurance which provides for regular payments beginning at a date not later than the date payments would have begun under the contract exchanged," "for an annuity contract," or "for a qualified long-term care insurance contract";
- "an annuity contract for an annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract"; or
- "a qualified long-term care insurance contract for a qualified long-term care insurance contract."
This is tax deferral, not forgiveness. Gain that is not recognized in the exchange remains in the new contract through the basis rules. A surrender works differently. Under 26 U.S.C. § 72(e)(5)(E), the rule for a "complete surrender, redemption, or maturity" applies, and the amount "shall be included in gross income, but only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract."
The listed directions run one way. The Treasury regulation states that "This section and section 1035 do not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract. In the case of such exchanges, any gain or loss shall be recognized" (26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1).
Receiving money or other property alongside the new contract changes the result. Section 1031(b) provides that in an exchange that would be within section 1035(a) except for that money or property, "the gain, if any, to the recipient shall be recognized, but in an amount not in excess of the sum of such money and the fair market value of such other property." Section 1031(c) adds that "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." The regulation states that such an exchange "does not come within the provisions of section 1035." Money or property received in this way is often called boot.
An outstanding policy loan raises a separate question at the exchange. How such a loan is treated depends on the facts of both contracts and is not resolved by section 1035's text.
Cost Basis: What Carries Over and What Does Not
Basis is the owner's tax investment in a contract. Section 72(e)(6) describes the "investment in the contract" as premiums paid minus amounts previously received that were excludable from gross income. The regulation provides that the basis of property acquired in a section 1035 exchange "shall be governed by section 1031(d)." That subsection provides that "the basis shall be the same as that of the property exchanged, decreased in the amount of any money received by the taxpayer and increased in the amount of gain or decreased in the amount of loss to the taxpayer that was recognized on such exchange."
In practice, the new contract steps into the old contract's basis. Gain that went unrecognized at the exchange stays embedded in the new contract and can surface when amounts are later taken out. A newly purchased contract then starts with the premiums paid into it.
Partial exchanges, in which only part of a contract's value moves, and the consolidation of several annuities into one raise allocation questions beyond the statute's text. How basis divides or combines in those transactions depends on the facts of the contracts involved. Basis figures on this page appear only in labelled hypotheticals.
Existing Guarantees: What an Exchange May Affect
An exchange ends one contract and starts another. The old contract's features do not move across unless the new contract itself provides them. That can include a guaranteed minimum interest rate, a no-lapse guarantee, a long-term care rider, a return-of-premium rider or a credited rate set years earlier.
Older contracts sometimes carry terms that newer contracts no longer offer. Whether a new contract matches, improves on or falls short of those terms is a contract-by-contract comparison. Product availability and feature terms vary by carrier and are confirmed with both carriers. The comparison depends on the facts of both contracts, and section 1035 does not decide it. Some of these older-contract questions are covered on the page about exchanging an old life policy.
Surrender Charges on the Old Contract
A surrender charge is a fee a contract deducts when it is ended or drawn down within a stated period. Section 1035 speaks only to recognition of gain or loss. It says nothing about surrender charges. Whether an exchange triggers the old contract's charges depends on that contract's terms.
Where a charge applies, the value transferred to the new contract is the value after the charge. That lower starting value is one of the costs an exchange has to overcome. Surrender-charge schedules, amounts and free-withdrawal provisions vary by carrier and contract and are confirmed with the carrier. For that reason this page states no percentage or schedule outside its hypotheticals. The page on surrender charges and exchanges explains what the tax rules do and do not cover.
New Surrender Period on the New Contract
Once a new contract is issued, its own terms govern withdrawals and surrender. Many contracts carry a surrender-charge period that runs from their own issue date. An owner whose old contract has already passed its surrender period may therefore take on a new one.
The length and structure of any new period vary by carrier and contract and are confirmed with the carrier. This matters for flexibility. A new period can limit how cheaply the owner could surrender, withdraw from or exchange the new contract later.
Death Benefit: Continuity and Gaps
For life insurance, coverage timing deserves close attention. The old contract's death benefit ends when that contract is surrendered or assigned. The new contract's death benefit begins under the new contract's terms. A gap is possible if the old contract ends before the new one is in force. Whether a gap exists depends on the exchange method and the carriers involved.
The new death benefit is set by the new contract, not by the old one. A new life insurance contract may require underwriting, which is the insurer's evaluation of the insured's age and health. Whether underwriting applies, and in what form, varies by carrier and contract type. Carrier procedures and timing vary and are confirmed with both carriers.
Have Questions About Your Policy?
Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!
Contract Features: Riders, Credits, and Product Type
New features are a common answer to why someone would 1035 exchange their existing policy. A new contract may offer a long-term care rider, an income rider or a different crediting method that the old contract lacks.
Section 1035(a) lists qualified long-term care insurance contracts as permitted destinations from a life insurance, endowment or annuity contract. Section 1035(b) also provides that a life insurance or annuity contract "shall not fail to be treated as" one "solely because a qualified long-term care insurance contract is a part of or a rider on such contract." The page on exchanges into long-term care treats that direction.
Product design is a separate question from tax treatment. Variable contracts place value in subaccounts that carry investment risk. Fixed and indexed contracts credit interest under different formulas. Section 1035 does not rank these designs. Whether a feature justifies surrender charges, a new surrender period and lost guarantees depends on the facts of both contracts. Product availability and feature terms vary by carrier and are confirmed with both carriers.
Liquidity: Access to Cash During and After an Exchange
An exchange is made by a direct exchange or an assignment of the contract. It can take place between two companies or within the same company. While the value moves, the owner generally does not have access to it. Timing varies by carrier and contract and is confirmed with both carriers.
After issue, access to cash follows the new contract's surrender-charge schedule and free-withdrawal provisions. A surrender-and-replace puts cash in the owner's hands between the two steps, but the surrender brings recognition of any gain. An owner who may need cash soon often weighs this factor heavily.
Policy Loans: Facts That Need Separate Attention
A policy loan is an advance from the insurer secured by the contract's value. A loan outstanding when the old contract is exchanged raises its own tax question. Section 1035's text does not answer it, and this page does not resolve it for any reader. The answer depends on the loan, both contracts and how the transaction is structured. The page on policy loans in an exchange discusses the issue further.
A loan taken under a contract outside an exchange is a different matter. Under 26 U.S.C. § 72(e)(10), a modified endowment contract is subject to rules that treat loans and certain other amounts as distributions. Under § 72(v), the taxable portion of an amount received under a modified endowment contract generally carries an additional tax "equal to 10 percent," with exceptions that include distributions "made on or after the date on which the taxpayer attains age 59½."
Long-Term Economics: What the Numbers Depend On
The case for an exchange is arithmetic before it is tax. Several factors decide it:
- surrender charges paid on the old contract;
- any new surrender period entered;
- differences in cost of insurance and expense charges between the two contracts;
- differences in credited rates or investment options;
- the tax deferral kept by the exchange compared with the tax cost of a surrender.
Hypothetical example. Assume an old contract with $100,000 of cash value, $50,000 of basis and a 10% surrender charge. Assume the new contract's annual charges are $500 lower than the old contract's, and that no money or loan is involved.
- Surrender charge: 10% × $100,000 = $10,000.
- Value transferred: $100,000 − $10,000 = $90,000.
- Gain not recognized at the exchange: $90,000 − $50,000 = $40,000.
- Charge savings over 10 years: $500 × 10 = $5,000.
- Comparison: $5,000 of assumed savings against the $10,000 surrender charge, before differences in crediting.
Under these assumptions alone, ten years of lower charges would not recover the surrender charge. Different assumptions would give a different result. This is a hypothetical illustration only and is not a determination of any reader's tax result. Carrier charges, credited rates and expense ratios vary by carrier and contract and are confirmed with both carriers.
When a 1035 Exchange May Fit
Several situations commonly lead owners to look at the 1035 exchange benefits:
- The old contract has substantial unrealized gain, and the owner wants that gain unrecognized for now.
- The old contract's internal costs are high compared with available alternatives.
- The owner wants a different contract type in a direction section 1035(a) lists, such as life insurance to an annuity, or an annuity to a qualified long-term care insurance contract.
- The old contract has underperformed compared with available alternatives.
These describe situations. They are not recommendations, and whether an exchange fits depends on the facts of both contracts. The permitted directions come from 26 U.S.C. § 1035(a) and 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1. The regulation also states that section 1035 "does not apply to such exchanges if the policies exchanged to not relate to the same insured." For annuities, the exchange "is limited to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the contract received in exchange as under the original contract." The obligee is the person to whom the contract's obligations are owed.
When Keeping the Old Contract or Surrendering May Fit
Some situations point owners toward keeping the contract they already have:
- The old contract carries valuable guarantees or riders that new contracts do not offer.
- The old contract has passed its surrender-charge period, and the owner values that flexibility.
- The old contract has little or no gain, so non-recognition matters less.
Other situations point owners toward a surrender:
- The contract is worth less than its basis.
- The owner needs the cash.
- The owner does not want a new surrender period.
Where a contract is worth less than its basis, the statutes speak in their own words. Section 1035(a) states that "No gain or loss shall be recognized," and section 1031(c) states that "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." This page does not state how a loss is treated. The treatment of a particular loss depends on the facts, and the page on a policy worth less than paid addresses it further. A comparison of the two paths appears on the page about a 1035 exchange versus surrender. These are descriptions of situations, not recommendations.
Decision Framework: Questions to Work Through
The decision turns on a handful of questions. A policyowner weighing an exchange typically examines:
- What is the old contract's cost basis, and how much gain is unrealized?
- What surrender charges apply to the old contract?
- Does the old contract have an outstanding loan?
- What guarantees or riders does the old contract carry that the new contract would not?
- What is the new contract's surrender period and charge schedule?
- Is the direction one that 26 U.S.C. § 1035(a) lists?
- Is the old contract a modified endowment contract, and would that status carry over?
- Are any ownership or insured changes involved?
On the last two points, the statute is specific. Under 26 U.S.C. § 7702A(a), a modified endowment contract is a contract meeting the federal tax definition of a life insurance contract that "is entered into on or after June 21, 1988" and "fails to meet the 7-pay test of subsection (b)." The definition also covers a contract "which is received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1) or this paragraph." A new life insurance contract received for one is therefore one too. An annuity contract received in exchange is not a modified endowment contract under section 7702A, because an annuity does not meet the federal tax definition of a life insurance contract.
Several topics need individual review of the contracts involved, by the insurers and a qualified tax professional: policy loans, ownership or insured changes, partial exchanges, MEC status and transaction sequencing.
Example Scenarios (Hypothetical)
Hypothetical Example 1: exchange with gain. Assume a life insurance contract with $100,000 of cash value, $60,000 of basis and a 5% surrender charge. Assume it is exchanged for a new life insurance contract, with no money, property or loan involved.
- Surrender charge: 5% × $100,000 = $5,000.
- Value transferred: $100,000 − $5,000 = $95,000.
- Gain not recognized under § 1035(a): $95,000 − $60,000 = $35,000.
- Basis under § 1031(d): $60,000, decreased by money received ($0) and increased by gain recognized ($0) = $60,000.
The surrender charge reduces the value transferred, not the basis. This is a hypothetical illustration only and is not a determination of any reader's tax result.
Hypothetical Example 2: surrender with gain. Assume the same contract is surrendered instead.
- Proceeds: $100,000 − $5,000 = $95,000.
- Amount above the investment in the contract under § 72(e)(5): $95,000 − $60,000 = $35,000, included in income for the surrender year.
- Any new contract's basis starts with the premiums paid into it.
Unlike Example 1, the $35,000 is recognized now rather than carried in the new contract. This is a hypothetical illustration only and is not a determination of any reader's tax result.
Hypothetical Example 3: MEC status. Assume a life insurance contract entered into after June 21, 1988 that failed the 7-pay test. Assume it is exchanged for a new contract that meets the federal tax definition of a life insurance contract.
- The old contract is a modified endowment contract under § 7702A(a)(1).
- The new contract was "received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1)."
- The new contract is therefore a modified endowment contract under § 7702A(a)(2).
This is a hypothetical illustration only and is not a determination of any reader's tax result.
Questions to Ask
Each party to an exchange can answer different questions.
For the old contract's carrier:
- What are the current cash surrender value and cost basis?
- Is there an outstanding loan?
- What surrender charges apply?
- Will the exchange be made by direct exchange or by assignment?
For the new contract's carrier:
- What surrender-charge schedule and free-withdrawal provisions apply?
- What underwriting is required?
- Which features, riders and guarantees does the contract offer?
For a qualified tax professional:
- What are the tax consequences, given the old contract's basis, gain and any loan?
- Is the direction one section 1035(a) lists?
- Do any ownership or insured changes affect the exchange?
- Is the old contract a modified endowment contract?
State replacement and suitability rules vary by state, and the carriers handle the replacement paperwork. Carrier forms, procedures and timing vary and are confirmed with both carriers. Whether a particular exchange meets section 1035 is confirmed with both carriers and a qualified tax professional.
Have Questions About Your Policy?
Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!
Questions & answers
Is a 1035 exchange a good idea?
It can be in some situations and not in others. The answer depends on the gain in the old contract, surrender charges, guarantees that would end, MEC status, the new contract's terms and liquidity needs. Section 1035(a) addresses only whether "gain or loss shall be recognized." It does not address whether the new contract is better.
Why would someone 1035 exchange their existing policy?
Owners commonly consider an exchange to change contract type in a direction section 1035(a) lists, to reach lower internal costs, or to obtain features such as a long-term care rider. They do so without recognizing gain at the exchange itself. Whether any of these reasons holds depends on both contracts.
What are the benefits of a 1035 exchange?
The federal benefit is the one section 1035(a) states: "No gain or loss shall be recognized" on a listed exchange. Basis carries over under section 1031(d). Any practical benefit, such as lower charges or new features, depends on the new contract's terms.
What are the pros and cons of a 1035 exchange?
On the pro side, the statute's non-recognition rule applies, and the owner may gain access to different contract designs. On the con side, there may be surrender charges, a new surrender period, lost guarantees, a possible coverage gap and modified endowment contract status carried over to a new life insurance contract. Weighing them depends on the facts of both contracts.
Can an annuity be exchanged back into life insurance under section 1035?
No. The Treasury regulation states that section 1035 does "not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract," and that "any gain or loss shall be recognized" in those exchanges.
Does keeping the old contract ever make more sense than exchanging?
Owners commonly consider keeping a contract that has valuable guarantees or riders, has passed its surrender period, or has little gain. These are descriptions of common situations, not recommendations for any reader.
1035 Exchange vs Surrender: Exchanging a Contract or Cashing It Out
1035 Exchange vs Surrender-and-Replace
1035 Exchange vs Borrowing Against the Policy
When Not to Do a 1035 Exchange
1035 Exchange vs 1031 Exchange: Insurance Contracts, Not Real Estate
