When Not to Do a 1035 Exchange: Disadvantages, Drawbacks and Situations to Reconsider
The drawbacks of a 1035 exchange under federal rules: carryover basis, MEC status under section 7702A, lost guarantees and riders, surrender charges and checks.
Published October 9, 2026 · Updated October 24, 2026
Short Answer: The Main Disadvantages of a 1035 Exchange
A 1035 exchange may work against an owner when the old contract carries surrender charges, older guarantees or riders, or a loan, or when the new contract restarts surrender charges or becomes a modified endowment contract. A check paid to the owner can be a taxable distribution under Rev. Rul. 2007-24.
A 1035 exchange is the replacement of one life insurance, endowment, annuity or qualified long-term care insurance contract with another in a way that 26 U.S.C. § 1035(a) treats as a non-recognition event: "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the contracts it lists. Owners who ask when not to do a 1035 exchange are usually comparing a new contract with one they already hold. 1035 Exchange sets out each drawback in turn, with the federal source behind it.
Exchange vs. Keeping the Contract: At a Glance
The table below sets out the general trade-offs between exchanging and keeping an existing contract. It describes patterns, not outcomes: the facts of the two contracts decide what actually happens.
| Issue | Exchanging under § 1035 | Keeping the existing contract |
|---|---|---|
| Tax timing | Gain is not recognized at the exchange if § 1035(a) applies. It stays deferred in the new contract. | No exchange occurs, and the gain stays deferred in the old contract. |
| Cost basis | Basis carries over under 26 U.S.C. § 1031(d). The owner does not get a fresh start. | Basis is unchanged. |
| Existing guarantees | The new contract's terms govern. Whether they match the old contract's terms turns on reading both contracts. | The terms are retained as the contract states them. |
| Surrender charges | Charges may apply on the old contract, and a new schedule may begin on the new one. | Any remaining schedule simply continues to run. |
| MEC status | The new life insurance contract may be or become a modified endowment contract under § 7702A. | An unchanged contract faces no new 7-pay test, unless a material change occurs. |
| Liquidity | A new surrender period may apply. | The existing schedule applies. |
| Riders and features | Whether any carry over depends on the new contract's terms and is confirmed with both carriers. | They remain in force on the terms of the contract. |
Carrier forms, fees and procedures vary and are confirmed with both carriers.
Tax Timing: When Deferred Gain Becomes a Disadvantage
Deferral helps an owner only if the transaction actually fits the statute. Section 1035(a) of the Internal Revenue Code provides that "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of" the listed contracts. That deferral is the main reason owners exchange, and it carries three limits.
The method. Rev. Rul. 2007-24 holds that "A taxpayer's receipt of a check issued by an insurance company under a non-qualified annuity contract is treated as a taxable distribution, even if the check is endorsed to a second insurance company for the purchase of a second annuity." The ruling adds: "The transaction is not characterized as a tax-free exchange under section 1035(a)(3) of the Code unless there is a direct exchange or assignment of the original contract." A direct exchange or an assignment may be made between two companies or within the same company. The steps of the process are set out on the site's page on the 1035 exchange process.
Money or other property. Money or property other than a permitted contract that the owner receives in an exchange is commonly called "boot." Under 26 U.S.C. § 1031(b), if an exchange would be within section 1035(a) except that the owner also receives "other property or money," then "the gain, if any, to the recipient shall be recognized, but in an amount not in excess of the sum of such money and the fair market value of such other property." Section 1031(c) adds that in such an exchange "no loss from the exchange shall be recognized." 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 states that such an exchange "does not come within the provisions of section 1035." The tax treatment of a particular loss depends on the facts and is not resolved here.
The direction. 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 provides that section 1035 does "not apply to transactions involving the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract. In the case of such exchanges, any gain or loss shall be recognized." The site's page on exchanges section 1035 excludes lists these cases.
Cost Basis: How Carryover Basis Can Work Against the Exchanging Owner
Basis does not reset in an exchange. The regulation states that "Determination of the basis of property acquired in an exchange under section 1035(a) shall be governed by section 1031(d)." That subsection provides that "the basis shall be the same as that of the property exchanged, decreased in the amount of any money received by the taxpayer and increased in the amount of gain or decreased in the amount of loss to the taxpayer that was recognized on such exchange."
In practice, the investment in the old contract follows the owner into the new one, and so does the untaxed gain. An owner hoping for a fresh starting point gets none. Rev. Rul. 2007-24 describes Rev. Rul. 2002-75 as concluding that assigning an annuity contract to a second company, which then deposits its cash surrender value into a pre-existing annuity contract owned by the same taxpayer, "qualifies as a tax-free exchange under § 1035." How basis is allocated in a partial exchange depends on the facts of the contracts.
Hypothetical example. The assumptions are a non-MEC contract, no money received at the exchange, no later premiums, no growth and no prior distributions.
- Old contract: basis $80,000 and value $120,000. The deferred gain is $120,000 − $80,000 = $40,000.
- After the exchange, the new contract carries the $80,000 basis under § 1031(d).
- The owner later surrenders the new contract for $120,000. Under 26 U.S.C. § 72(e)(5)(E) and (A)(ii), an amount received on complete surrender is included in gross income "to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract": $120,000 − $80,000 = $40,000.
The figures are illustrative only and do not stand for any owner's contract.
Existing Guarantees: What an Older Contract May Offer That a New One Will Not
An older policy is a distinct situation, because an older contract can carry terms a new one will not. Some older contracts contain features such as a guaranteed minimum interest rate, a guaranteed death benefit or other provisions written into that specific contract.
These features are contractual, not statutory. Section 1035 governs whether gain or loss is recognized. It does not move a contract's promises from one contract to another. After an exchange, the new contract's terms govern from its own issue date, and the old contract's terms end with the old contract.
Which guarantees an existing contract contains, and whether any new contract offers comparable terms, turns on reading both contracts. Product availability varies by carrier and is confirmed with both carriers.
Surrender Charges on the Existing Contract: A Cost That Reduces the Exchanged Value
A surrender charge is a contractual deduction an insurer takes when a contract is surrendered before its surrender charge period ends, and the contract's own terms say whether one also applies to an exchange. A charge on the old contract reduces the value that reaches the new contract.
Surrender charge schedules vary by contract and carrier and are confirmed with the carrier of the existing contract. Whether a charge affects the tax result of a particular exchange depends on the facts of the exchange. The site's page on surrender charges in an exchange addresses that question separately.
New Surrender Period: Starting Over on Liquidity
Every new contract has its own terms, and many include their own surrender charge schedule that runs from the new issue date. An owner who leaves a contract whose charges have expired may take on new charges in the replacement.
The length and structure of a new surrender period are contract terms that vary by contract and carrier and are confirmed with the new carrier. An owner who exchanged hoping for easier access to funds may find the new contract equally restrictive, or more so, while its schedule runs.
Death Benefit: How an Exchange Can Affect the Benefit Amount and MEC Status
The new contract's death benefit comes from the new contract. It is not inherited from the old one, and it may be higher, lower or structured differently.
MEC status is the larger issue. 26 U.S.C. § 7702A(a) defines a "modified endowment contract" as a contract meeting the federal tax requirements for a life insurance contract "(1) which (A) is entered into on or after June 21, 1988, and (B) fails to meet the 7-pay test of subsection (b), or (2) which is received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1) or this paragraph." Under the 7-pay test, a contract fails if the amount paid in during its first seven contract years exceeds the net level premiums for a contract paid up after seven level annual premiums. A life insurance contract received in exchange for a MEC is therefore itself a MEC. An annuity contract received in exchange for one is not a MEC under § 7702A, because it does not meet the federal tax requirements for a life insurance contract.
A material change also matters. Under § 7702A(c)(3)(A), a material change makes the contract "a new contract entered into on the day on which such material change takes effect" for the 7-pay test, with adjustments for the cash surrender value. Under § 7702A(c)(3)(B), the term "includes any increase in the death benefit" or in a qualified additional benefit. It excludes increases attributable to premiums needed to fund the lowest level of the death benefit and qualified additional benefits payable in the first seven contract years, and to the crediting of interest or other earnings on those premiums. To the extent regulations provide, it also excludes certain cost-of-living increases.
The consequences come from section 72. Under § 72(e)(10), paragraphs (2)(B) and (4)(A) apply to a MEC. Section 72(v) increases the tax by "10 percent of the portion of such amount which is includible in gross income." That additional tax does not apply to a distribution made on or after age 59½, one attributable to disability, or one that is part of a series of substantially equal periodic payments.
Have Questions About Your Policy?
Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!
Contract Features: Riders, Options and Terms That Do Not Transfer
Riders are add-on provisions of the contract that issued them. Examples include long-term care riders, waiver of premium and guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefits. An exchange replaces the contract, and the old contract's riders and optional benefits do not move to the new one.
Whether the new contract offers comparable features, and at what cost, depends on its terms. For life coverage, it may also depend on the insured's insurability when the exchange is made. Rider availability and cost vary by carrier and contract and are confirmed with both carriers.
Liquidity: How an Exchange Can Restrict Access to Contract Value
Two forces limit access after an exchange. The first is the new contract's surrender charge schedule. The second is the deferral itself: deferred gain remains subject to income tax when it is distributed, so deferral postpones the tax rather than removing it.
An owner who expects to need contract value soon may therefore find that an exchange narrows access instead of widening it.
Policy Loans: Why an Outstanding Loan Complicates an Exchange
An outstanding loan on the existing contract at the time of the exchange is a complication that the general rules of section 1035 do not settle on their own. Whether and how a loan at the exchange is taxed depends on the facts of both contracts and how the carriers handle the loan. The site's page on exchanges with policy loans covers that topic.
Several topics need individual review of the contracts involved, by the insurers and a qualified tax professional: policy loans, MEC status, partial exchanges, ownership or insured changes, the sequencing of loans, surrenders and exchanges, and the treatment of any loss. A loan taken under a contract outside an exchange is a separate matter governed by section 72.
Long-Term Economics: When the Numbers May Not Favor an Exchange
Several costs and benefits combine to shape an exchange's long-run result:
- surrender charges paid on the old contract;
- the cost structure of the new contract;
- the length of the new surrender period;
- the features lost and the features gained;
- how distributions from the new contract are taxed.
Carryover basis keeps the deferred gain in place, to be taxed on later distribution. An exchange that pays surrender charges on the old contract and starts a new schedule on the new one may need considerable time before any advantage of the new contract offsets those costs. That is a general pattern, not a computed result. The economics of a given exchange depend on the facts of both contracts, evaluated with both carriers and a qualified tax professional.
When Keeping the Existing Contract May Fit the Owner's Situation
Certain facts tend to point toward keeping the current contract. These are descriptions, not recommendations:
- The existing contract is past its surrender charge period and carries contractual guarantees that new contracts may not offer.
- The contract has an outstanding loan whose treatment at an exchange is uncertain.
- The insured's health has changed, and the new life contract would require new underwriting.
- The contract has a low basis, and the owner expects to hold it long term. The tax treatment of death benefits is a separate topic.
An exchange that would involve a change of owner or insured raises separate questions that depend on the facts of the contracts. State replacement and suitability rules vary by state, and the carriers handle the replacement paperwork.
When an Exchange May Fit the Owner's Situation
Other facts make an exchange worth evaluating further. Again, these are descriptions, not recommendations:
- The existing contract has high internal costs compared with available alternatives.
- The owner wants a different kind of contract, and § 1035(a) lists that direction: for example, "a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract."
- The contract has little or no gain, so carryover basis matters less.
- The contract is past its surrender charge period.
The listed directions do not run in reverse. Section 1035(a)(3) lists an annuity contract only "for an annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract," and 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 provides that section 1035 does not apply to the exchange of an endowment contract or annuity contract for a life insurance contract, nor an annuity contract for an endowment contract. The site's page on changing policy type discusses which type changes the statute lists. Whether a particular exchange fits § 1035 depends on the facts of both contracts.
Decision Framework: Questions to Work Through Before Exchanging
These are questions an owner and the owner's advisers would typically be able to answer before an exchange:
- Does 26 U.S.C. § 1035(a) list this exchange direction?
- Do the contracts relate to the same insured? Are the obligees the same, as 26 C.F.R. § 1.1035-1 requires for annuities?
- Is the existing contract still within its surrender charge period?
- Does the existing contract carry guarantees or riders that will not transfer?
- Does the existing contract have an outstanding policy loan?
- Is either contract a MEC, or would the new life contract be one under § 7702A?
- Will the transaction be a direct exchange or assignment, rather than a check to the owner, as Rev. Rul. 2007-24 describes?
- What surrender charge period does the new contract carry?
The questions surface facts; they do not decide anything. Their answers depend on both contracts and are reviewed with both carriers and a qualified tax professional.
Example Scenarios (Hypothetical)
Hypothetical example 1: a surrender charge reduces the value exchanged. Assumptions: Contract A has a cash value of $100,000 and a surrender charge of $7,000 that applies on exchange.
- $100,000 − $7,000 = $93,000 transferred.
- The new contract begins with $93,000.
Actual charges vary by contract and carrier.
Hypothetical example 2: deferred gain survives the exchange. Assumptions: Contract A is not a MEC, with a basis of $60,000 and a cash value of $100,000. No money is received at the exchange, and there is no later growth or premium.
- Deferred gain: $100,000 − $60,000 = $40,000.
- The new contract carries the $60,000 basis.
- On a later complete surrender for $100,000, the amount included in income under § 72(e)(5) is $100,000 − $60,000 = $40,000.
Hypothetical example 3: MEC status follows the exchange. Assumptions: Contract A is a life insurance contract that is a MEC, and the owner exchanges it for life insurance Contract B.
- Under § 7702A(a)(2), Contract B, "received in exchange for a contract described in paragraph (1)," is itself a MEC.
- Distributions from Contract B fall under § 72(e)(10). Under § 72(v), any includible portion may carry the 10 percent additional tax unless one of that subsection's exceptions applies.
MEC status in any real case turns on the contracts' own facts.
Questions to Ask
For the existing contract's carrier:
- What surrender charge applies now, if any?
- Is there an outstanding loan?
- Which contractual guarantees would end with the contract?
For the new contract's carrier:
- What is the new surrender charge period and schedule?
- Will the transaction be processed as a direct exchange or assignment?
- Which riders are available, and at what cost?
For a qualified tax professional:
- What is the existing contract's basis?
- Would the exchange produce MEC status?
- Does it involve any change of owner or insured?
Carrier forms, procedures and timing vary and are confirmed with both carriers.
Have Questions About Your Policy?
Contact our local California life insurance advisor 7 days a week to get all your questions answered. We are here to help you!
Questions & answers
What are the main disadvantages of a 1035 exchange?
The main drawbacks are surrender charges on the old contract, a new surrender period, lost guarantees and riders, carryover basis and possible MEC status. There is also the risk of a taxable distribution if a check is paid to the owner, as Rev. Rul. 2007-24 describes. How much each matters depends on the facts of both contracts.
Can a 1035 exchange trigger a modified endowment contract?
It can for life insurance. Under 26 U.S.C. § 7702A(a)(2), a life insurance contract that is received in exchange for a MEC is itself a MEC. A new contract entered into on or after June 21, 1988 that fails the 7-pay test is also a MEC, and a material change restarts the test under § 7702A(c)(3)(A).
Do surrender charges apply in a 1035 exchange?
They may, depending on the contract. A charge on the old contract reduces the value exchanged, and the new contract may start its own schedule. Schedules vary by contract and carrier and are confirmed with both carriers.
What happens to the cost basis when a contract is exchanged?
It carries over. Under 26 U.S.C. § 1031(d), the basis "shall be the same as that of the property exchanged," adjusted for money received and gain or loss recognized. Deferred gain therefore remains in the new contract.
Does a 1035 exchange eliminate the tax on deferred gain?
No. Section 1035(a) provides that no gain "shall be recognized" at the exchange, and carryover basis keeps the gain in the new contract, where it may be taxed on later distribution under section 72.
What happens if a 1035 exchange is not done as a direct transfer?
Rev. Rul. 2007-24 treats a check issued under a non-qualified annuity contract as a taxable distribution, even if the owner endorses it to a second company. The ruling states that the transaction does not fall within § 1035(a)(3) "unless there is a direct exchange or assignment of the original contract."
What is bad about exchanging an older life insurance policy?
An older contract may carry contractual terms, such as a guaranteed minimum interest rate or a guaranteed death benefit, that end with it. Whether a new contract's terms justify giving them up depends on both contracts.
1035 Exchange vs Surrender: Exchanging a Contract or Cashing It Out
1035 Exchange vs Surrender-and-Replace
1035 Exchange vs Borrowing Against the Policy
Should You Do a 1035 Exchange? Questions to Answer First
1035 Exchange vs 1031 Exchange: Insurance Contracts, Not Real Estate
Exchanging an Underperforming Policy or Annuity Under Section 1035
